Home / Cyber / Digital sovereignty: the temptation of states without territory

Digital sovereignty: the temptation of states without territory

By Arthur Martin, artificial intelligence entrepreneur, and Sébastien Boussois, geopolitician

Digital technologies are revolutionising our economies, our societies, and now even our way of thinking about the state. As work becomes increasingly dematerialised, as currencies circulate on cryptographic networks, and as identity becomes digital, a question long relegated to science fiction is now entering the public debate: can a state exist without territory, without a physical population, and without physical borders?

For several years now, the idea of “digital states” has been gaining ground in certain technological and entrepreneurial circles. At a time when platforms are already structuring a growing part of our economic and social lives, some are imagining a new stage: that of a sovereignty no longer based on geography but on networks. But behind this ambition lies a deeper question: can technology truly replace the political foundations of the modern state?

The emergence of digital states: a promise of deterritorialised sovereignty

For the past decade, several projects claiming to be “digital states” have emerged. They are driven by libertarian entrepreneurs, techno-utopians, or activists convinced that the modern state has become too slow, too bureaucratic, and too restrictive in the face of the rapid pace of technological change. Liberland, which aims to establish itself in a disputed area between Croatia and Serbia, and Bitnation, which proposes a citizenship based on blockchain, embody this radical desire to detach sovereignty from the land and territorial constraints.

In their vision, the state of the future would no longer be a geographical space but a platform. Membership would be voluntary, rules coded in computer protocols, and governance ensured by algorithmic or community-based mechanisms. Some even speak of “network states”, global communities capable of organising themselves politically online before, perhaps, establishing a minimal territorial presence. The idea appeals to a segment of the world’s young entrepreneurs, fuelled by the start-up dream and the promise of a world where technology would correct the sluggishness of politics.

Their promise rests on a simple premise: the modern state is obsolete, while technology offers more agile governance, based on voluntary participation and contracts rather than authority. Citizenship would no longer be innate; it would be acquired through choice, much like choosing a digital platform or online community today. In this world, sovereignty would become flexible, portable, almost personalised.

But behind this promise of freedom lies a structural fragility. None of these projects currently meets the fundamental criteria of a state as defined by international law and political tradition: no international recognition, no monopoly on the legitimate use of force, no judicial system capable of asserting itself beyond voluntary participation. In reality, these experiments are more akin to ideological and technological experimentation than genuine political sovereignty.

The question of citizenship is central here. In these models, the citizen often becomes a user, sometimes even a customer, free to come and go as they please. Yet citizenship is not simply a set of negotiable rights. It implies duties, a necessary solidarity, acceptance of a collective, and sometimes sacrifice. It also presupposes mutual responsibility between the individual and the political community. Can a state without mandatory taxation, without binding justice and without collective responsibility still claim to embody anything other than an expanded private club?

This transformation of the citizen into a “member” or a “subscriber” raises an even deeper question: can a sustainable society be built solely on the basis of permanent voluntary participation? Political societies have historically been built on compromises, obligations, and institutions capable of enduring beyond individual preferences. On the contrary, an absolute contractual logic risks undermining any form of political stability.

The limits of the model: why sovereignty remains rooted in reality

Faced with these digital grey areas, traditional states actually retain powerful levers. First and foremost, the law, by strictly regulating digital identity, citizenship, cryptocurrency taxation, and the legal liability of platforms. Without legal recognition, virtual citizenship remains worthless for travel, contracting, or receiving effective protection. Passports, courts, police forces, and diplomatic institutions remain deeply rooted in territorial reality.

States also possess a decisive advantage that technological rhetoric sometimes tends to overlook: control of physical infrastructure. Virtual worlds and blockchains rely on very concrete material realities. Fibre-optic networks, satellites, data centres, energy production, and security infrastructure are all located on sovereign territories. Even the most abstract digital universe ultimately depends on a physical world administered by states.

This does not mean, however, that these experiments are without consequences. Virtual states are unlikely to become powers comparable to major nations or even large technology companies. They possess neither armed forces, nor recognised diplomacy, nor deterrent capabilities. Their influence, however, could be exerted in other ways.

A crisis of confidence in traditional institutions

Their true power lies in their ability to bring together transnational communities, to test new forms of governance and to spread alternative norms. In this sense, they contribute to a broader transformation of political authority in the digital age. The risk is not the sudden disappearance of the state, but rather the gradual erosion of some of its functions in favour of private actors or global, networked communities.

Ultimately, these projects reveal above all a crisis of confidence in traditional institutions. If the idea of a digital state holds appeal, it is because some citizens feel that existing political structures are no longer keeping pace with the speed of economic and technological change. The attraction of these alternative models is therefore less an institutional revolution than a political symptom.

Digital states are certainly not the future of sovereignty. They are a critical mirror held up to it. They reflect a mistrust of institutions and a persistent illusion: that a society can function durably without structured political authority. Sovereignty cannot be downloaded. It is built over time, through a balance between individual freedom, collective responsibility and institutions capable of guaranteeing the stability of a community.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.