Home / Analysis / Beneath the Atlantic, a silent war on Canada’s doorstep

Beneath the Atlantic, a silent war on Canada’s doorstep

By Didier Aubrais, Founding President of the Cercle Canadien francophone d’Analyse Géopolitique

In the icy depths of the North Atlantic, far from prying eyes and the din of open conflict, a strategic battle is being fought in which Canada has become one of the unwitting players. Increased Russian underwater activity, the vulnerability of transatlantic cables, sensitive shipping routes: this discreet war, confirmed by military and diplomatic sources, is redrawing the stakes of sovereignty in the North Atlantic.

Some wars break out in plain sight; others unfold in absolute silence, far from the cameras, beneath the cold waters of the North Atlantic. For several years now, an invisible confrontation has been playing out in the ocean depths, right off Canada’s coasts. It is a reality now borne out by military reports, official statements and corroborating journalistic investigations.

For the bulk of our global communications relies on infrastructure as vital as it is little known: submarine cables. Nearly 95% of international digital traffic travels not by satellite but through more than 400 cables laid on the ocean floor, several of which link Europe to North America along Canada’s maritime approaches. Financial transactions, government communications, military data, private exchanges: the entire architecture of today’s digital world depends on these invisible and extremely vulnerable arteries.

This fragility explains the growing interest the major powers are taking in them. Russia, China, the United States and NATO now regard the seabed as a strategic domain in its own right. In 2023, General Glen VanHerck, then commander of NORAD, stated that Russia was deploying submarines capable of operating close to Canada’s economic zones. The following year, a Pentagon report confirmed a stepping-up of Russian submarine activity in the North Atlantic, notably near Newfoundland and the entrance to the Gulf of St Lawrence. Former Royal Canadian Navy officers have also acknowledged that foreign submarines had been detected approaching this strategic area, which is particularly difficult to monitor.

The St Lawrence is indeed far more than a mere shipping route. Its mouth forms a major geostrategic corridor. Several vital transatlantic cables pass through it before reaching Montreal and Toronto. For a hostile power, mapping, intercepting or potentially sabotaging them would offer a considerable advantage. Added to this is the route’s military importance, as it is regularly used by Canadian, American and allied NATO vessels. Finally, the very geography of the gulf – vast, deep and acoustically complex – lends itself to stealthy approaches by submarines that are hard to detect quickly.

The incident off the coast of Spain in 2024 was, moreover, a stark reminder of the strategic centrality of the seabed. A ship carrying sensitive technological equipment bound for Russia sank there in an area crossed by several critical cables. The Spanish authorities immediately secured the wreck to prevent any foreign power from recovering the cargo. The affair served as a wake-up call in European foreign ministries and within NATO: undersea rivalries are no longer a theoretical hypothesis but a permanent operational reality.

What is unfolding beneath the Atlantic today does not fit the conventional forms of warfare. This is a grey war: diffuse and often denied. Submarines cruising near strategic cables, underwater drones tasked with mapping the ocean floor, oceanographic vessels discreetly observing sensitive areas, cable ruptures described as “accidental”, strategic cargoes swallowed by the sea: all these events fuel a conflict that has never been officially declared. States speak cautiously of “unusual movements”, “suspicious activities” or “potential risks”. But everyone knows that the seabed has become a new theatre of strategic competition.

The floor of the Atlantic is now emerging as one of the most sensitive fronts of the 21st century. It is a silent war, without explosions or spectacular images, yet its implications for the sovereignty, communications and economic security of Western states are considerable. Canada, long shielded by a kind of strategic innocence, can no longer ignore this reality. What is at stake beneath the Atlantic goes beyond a mere espionage contest: it is a struggle for control of critical infrastructure, shipping routes and the information flows that underpin modern societies.

The question, then, is no longer whether this silent war exists. It is now whether Canada is truly ready to respond to it.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.