Often described as the “new black gold”, metals lie at the heart of every strategic ambition. Construction metals, semiconductors, rare earths and so on: the scientific distinctions between all these metals and their uses are often poorly understood, but everyone agrees that we are increasingly dependent on them. To meet this exponentially growing demand, states are looking for new mines to exploit, even on the seabed, which offers immense potential but not without negative consequences. We take a closer look.
Metal ores in deep waters have been known about since the 1970s, but in recent years they have attracted growing interest from many private and public players. The race to mine the seabed is still only in its infancy. Yet exploration projects are multiplying, and almost all of them pursue the same goal: to study the feasibility of mining projects. France, which has the second-largest exclusive economic zone, must take a clear position on the issues raised by such projects. Indeed, technical, scientific, ecological, social and health-related details must be provided in order to understand the devastating consequences that deep-sea mining could entail.
The current state of the mining sector: taking stock and looking ahead
How demand for metals has changed since the 1950s
To understand how demand for metals will evolve in the coming years, we must first take stock of demand to date. Indeed, this demand has accelerated exponentially since the 1950s. For example, according to the World Mineral Statistics Yearbook, the quantity of aluminium produced in 1950 amounted to a few million tonnes, whereas in 2020 it exceeded 70 million. Another example is provided by the association SystEx, which, drawing on official data from the United States Geological Survey, shows that the quantity of iron extracted increased elevenfold between 1950 and 2020. Looking at production growth rates, this exponential trend appears even more worrying. The association calculated the average annual growth rate for several metals. For iron, this rate is 3.7%, which at first glance may not seem particularly high. Yet if such a rate remains constant over 25 years, production effectively doubles. From the 2000s onwards, the development of communication and digital technologies led to increased production of new metals, such as gallium, which is used in LEDs. Gallium production increased twentyfold between 1973 and 2020 and its average annual rate exceeded 10%, again according to SystEx. These few figures bear witness to the dizzying acceleration in metal production, and they do not yet include the quantities projected to deliver ecological transition plans.
Researchers had hoped that we would manage to achieve decoupling. This economic and ecological concept envisaged that economic growth would continue, but with an ever-diminishing need for resources. In other words, absolute decoupling means an increase in GDP combined with a decrease in the use of a given resource. Added to this theory is the “environmental Kuznets curve”, which predicted first a rise in pollution as income increased and then, if income continued to rise, a fall in pollution. The resulting curve, plotting changes in pollution against changes in income, takes the shape of an inverted U. However, recent years have shown that both theories are wrong, or incomplete. It would appear that trends are the opposite of a decoupling scenario. We need more and more resources.
To the figures cited above must be added the production forecasts required to carry out ecological transition plans. Scientists have been warning about this crisis for decades, yet it is only since the 2010s that ecological transition plans have proliferated. These plans follow on from the Green Deal, such as the European Fit for Fifty Five plan, which aims to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 55% by 2050. The International Energy Agency uses several scenarios to draw up its forecasts. The so-called “sustainable development” forecasts, that is, the forecasts under the scenario in which the Paris Agreement is honoured, predict that installed electrical capacity will triple compared with 2021 by 2050, and that demand for electric vehicles will increase 25-fold, again compared with 2021.
This growing demand for energy is driving exponential demand for metals. According to the report by the Eurometaux group, lithium production is expected to increase 21-fold by 2050 compared with 2020 under the most ambitious scenario. For the energy transition, the highest scenarios correspond to an increase of around 80 million tonnes in metals produced between 2020 and 2050. For the engineer Aurore Stephand, these forecasts are alarming. First of all, bringing a mine into operation takes several years. A site must first be found, an operating licence obtained and the infrastructure built; taken together, these stages last at least 10 years. Moreover, the mines in operation are already working at full production capacity. These various considerations lead to the conclusion that energy transition plans are utterly unrealistic from the standpoint of metal production.
Understanding the negative externalities of land-based mines to anticipate those of potential deep-sea mines
Mines often have disastrous social and environmental consequences. It is worth recalling in particular that, contrary to what part of the public believes, “dirty” mines are not found only in less developed countries. The United States and Australia are among the countries operating the largest number of mines. According to the 2022 report by the association SystEx, the mining industry is the industry that produces the most waste and is responsible for the largest number of socio-environmental conflicts. The problems associated with mines are many. First of all, the metals extracted account for only a few per cent of the tonnes of material processed in mines. For gold, the concentration is only a few ppb, that is, a few parts per billion. Several tonnes of material must therefore be brought to the surface and processed to obtain just a few grams of the metal sought. This metal comes with other metals, some of them particularly toxic, such as lead or arsenic, which end up in mining waste, often discharged into water. The mining industry also consumes large quantities of water and energy, particularly the steel sector, which accounts for 7% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Technological advances in the mining industry since the 19th century have been linked solely to digital development and are aimed at automation, among other things. They therefore do not remedy the various externalities mentioned above. Extraction techniques have remained almost unchanged since the last century, and their main objective is to reduce production costs.
The end of a mine’s life is also an environmental issue. Few mining sites are rehabilitated, and even if efforts can be made to restore the fauna and flora as far as possible, it is impossible to return to the state that existed before extraction began. In South Africa, fewer than 1% of mines reaching the end of their working life are rehabilitated; the rest are simply abandoned as they are, with no consequences whatsoever for the operators. Yet the communities living around them are condemned to live in a toxic environment for decades. Scientists estimate, for example, that the former mine on Mount Polley in Canada will not return to a normal state for several thousand years. On top of these problems comes the risk of dam failures, which result in mining waste being spilled over several tens of kilometres at speeds of up to 110 km/h. According to Aurore Stephand, there are between 4 and 7 major mining dam failures a year involving at least one death. Legal texts do not provide for negative externalities to be factored into mining permits. The financial, ecological and health consequences of mines should therefore be incorporated and better anticipated.
Deep-sea mining
What lies at the bottom of the oceans?
To understand why deep-sea mining is an unprecedented technological challenge, it is necessary to explain in what form and where the metals are found. There are three types of deposit: hydrothermal sulphides, polymetallic nodules and crusts. These deposits take several tens of thousands of years, or even millions, to form, which in itself puts the enthusiasm surrounding their discovery into perspective.
Hydrothermal sulphides are found mainly in volcanic areas at a depth of around 2 kilometres, near mid-ocean ridges, for example. In the areas where they form, seawater is heated as it passes close to magma chambers. As it heats up, the seawater becomes more acidic and laden with metals, turning into a hydrothermal fluid. Once it reaches a temperature above 500 degrees, the fluid’s density falls and it gradually rises towards the surface. Contact between the fluid and colder currents leads to the formation of sulphides in the shape of small chimneys rich in copper or silver, for example. There are reportedly 10 exploitable areas, most of them in the Clarion-Clipperton Fracture Zone in the Pacific Ocean.
Nodules are found on abyssal plains with low sedimentation rates, that is, where solid particles settle slowly in seawater, at depths of between 3 and 6 kilometres. These small spherical accumulations of matter are rich in manganese, iron and lithium, among others, and result from the precipitation of metals dissolved in seawater. In 1986, the geologist Enrico Bonatti put forward four possible formation processes, with growth thought to be in the order of a centimetre per million years. Today, how they form still seems rather poorly understood. They range in size from 5 to 12 centimetres. Crusts, for their part, result from precipitation not around a nucleus but over large surfaces in areas where sedimentation rates are virtually zero, on the flanks of volcanoes, for example. They are rich in iron and manganese.
These three types of deposit do indeed contain significant concentrations of metals. However, these grades need to be put into perspective: the vast majority are equivalent to, or even lower than, those of land-based deposits. SystEx puts forward several figures, drawing in particular on research by the Ecorys group. Only tellurium in crusts and copper in sulphides have higher grades in marine deposits than in land-based mines (for tellurium, grades of around 60 grams per tonne are found, compared with 0.1 to 1 gram per tonne in land-based deposits, and for copper the rate is 5% in sulphides, compared with 0.3 to 2% on land). For other metals, grades are low ; this is the case, for example, with lithium, for which land-based grades range from 500 to 15,000 grams per tonne, compared with 131 grams per tonne in marine deposits. Moreover, to understand these figures, one must understand the calculations from which they derive. Studies estimate, for example, that there could be 6,000 million tonnes of manganese on the seabed. However, the calculation methods used to arrive at these figures are imprecise : they are projections, the uncertainties are considerable and all the assumptions are open to qualification. Indeed, the deposits are heterogeneous and their exploitability has not been the subject of in-depth studies.
The exploitability of deposits : mounting technical challenges
Leaving aside calculations that are sometimes questionable and often uncertain, every deposit envisaged in the studies would have to be mined to reach the colossal quantities of metals being put forward. Researchers at the International Seabed Authority, for example, assumed a minable area of nodules of 3.83 million square kilometres, yet this is a vast area in light of what the land-based mining industry is capable of. Indeed, it would mean mining an area larger than Argentina, which covers 2.780 million square kilometres. By way of comparison, one of the largest open-pit gold mines, the Kalgoorlie Super Pit in Australia, measures no more than 3.5 km long and 1.5 km wide. Attempting to mine such an area therefore appears unviable.
The difficulties involved in deep-sea mining also lie in the depth at which the deposits are found, which can reach around 6 kilometres (temperatures are extremely cold and the pressure is roughly 600 times greater than at the surface), and in their distance from the coast. To date, one of the only exploration projects has been Solwara 1, and it failed. It was developed by a Canadian company called Nautilus Minerals and was intended to mine areas off Papua New Guinea. Lacking the financial means, the company had to abandon the project in 2019. It nevertheless gives an idea of the resources needed to exploit seabed deposits. Three remotely operated vehicles had been designed: the Auxiliary Cutter (for the initial cutting), the Bulk Cutter (for the second, finer cutting phase) and the Collection Machine (for pumping up the collected material and bringing it to the surface). They weigh between 180 and 280 tonnes and each operates with a power of between 1.8 and 2.5 megawatts (by way of comparison, a wind turbine delivers such power when operating under optimal conditions). This type of machine would very probably require the use of fossil fuels. Moreover, a production support vessel would have to remain on the surface to gather the collected material and begin processing the nodules or other deposits, and it too would require a considerable amount of energy.
Processing marine ores also poses a technical challenge that scientists have yet to solve, as it differs from the processes used for land-based ores. Porosity and water content are far higher. A preliminary dewatering stage is therefore required to separate the ores from residual sediment and to reduce the moisture content, using various techniques such as centrifugal pumping or passage through hydrocyclones. The metals can then be extracted by pyrometallurgy (heating), by flotation or by hydrometallurgy (electrolysis, for example). However, these techniques appear difficult to apply to marine ores, since the metals are intermingled with the hydrothermal sulphides or the nodules at the nanometric scale. In the case of nodules, they would first have to be ground extremely finely (to the order of a hundred micrometres, equivalent to metre) and the crystal lattice of the oxides of which they are composed would have to be broken down completely.
All these stages of production therefore appear to make little sense in economic or energy terms, given the current state of the extraction techniques being developed. The amount of energy and resources needed to bring to the surface ores that ultimately prove just as attractive as land-based ores, or even less so, seems far too great. The energy transition, which is admittedly partly behind this exponential demand for metals, pursues one objective: meeting the Paris Agreement. The energy demands of such projects are entirely at odds with that objective. For even if companies were to develop financially viable projects, these would very probably cause an unprecedented ecological and social disaster, according to SystEx and many other associations, researchers and civil parties.
The social and environmental consequences of deep-sea mining
The marine ecosystem, in all its complexity, remains a great source of mystery to humankind. Every expedition uncovers new species, each more fascinating than the last, and the natural balance that exists between all these organisms is still poorly understood. Exploration and exploitation both have impacts on marine life, the extent of which remains unknown to this day. During the exploration phase, the noise and light that accompany research systems disturb deep-sea species by altering their environment. During the exploitation phase, every living species on the deposits is, of course, destroyed, and harmful consequences can be observed beyond the area being mined, several kilometres away. Underwater vehicles stir up sediment plumes, that is, clouds of particles that have accumulated on the seabed. Although research is still under way, scientists agree that these plumes could smother part of the fauna and flora and lead to the release of several toxic metals. Moreover, the concentration of elements in the seawater would be altered, notably the concentration of nutrients. All of these effects were confirmed during the exploration and testing project launched by the Belgian company Global Sea Mineral Resources in the Pacific in 2021.
Finally, the ocean acts as a “carbon sink” in ways that are still poorly understood. Scientific research has so far established that this function stems from both physical and biological processes. Water movements sequester carbon on the seabed, while phytoplankton consume the carbonate ions derived from carbon dissolved in the water to produce calcium carbonate, which in turn stores the carbon through sedimentation. By scraping up these sediments, remotely operated vehicles could release the stored carbon and disrupt the ocean’s role as a “carbon sink”.
These environmental problems are compounded by social and economic concerns. Communities living on coasts near seabed mineral deposits very often depend on fishing and have a deep, spiritual relationship with marine life. According to SystEx, the socio-economic consequences of potential mining operations remain far too underestimated. The association calls for systematic consultation of the communities concerned in order to assess the impacts, risks and benefits of this industry, and to uphold the fundamental principle of free, prior and informed consent.
Yet despite all these warnings, a number of arguments are being put forward in favour of such mining. For countries such as France, the aim is to regain sovereignty over mineral production, and to reduce their dependence on China, which currently produces 90% of rare earths (although, contrary to their name, they are found in the soils of every continent), while diversifying our sources of production to address a potential shortage of metals (which, according to the think tank Zenon, would be due first and foremost to supply flows and production capacity, and only secondarily to geological constraints).
From exploration to exploitation: the current state of international regulations and debates
The 29th session of the Assembly of the International Seabed Authority (ISA), held in Kingston, Jamaica, from 15 July to 2 August, failed to reach a consensus at the close of debates that this year focused mainly on whether to authorise the exploitation of deep-sea deposits. However, the 168 member countries (170 since the Assembly) that make up this UN agency, created in 1994, did agree not to issue exploitation licences in the absence of a mining code. Une is tasked with regulating exploration and exploitation in the Area, that is, the marine territories that fall under no other national jurisdiction. Discussions held at ISA meetings in recent years have pitted several groups against one another: countries such as Russia and India, which are pushing for swift authorisation in view of dwindling land-based resources; those such as Canada, Chile and even China, which advocate waiting for further scientific advice; and those that are categorically opposed to any future exploitation. France belongs to the last group and publicly came out against any form of deep-sea exploitation in 2022, following Emmanuel Macron’s announcement at COP27 in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt.
The Assembly elected its next Secretary-General, Brazil’s Leticia Carvalho, who will succeed Michael Lodge from 1 January 2025. Lodge, who had been particularly supportive of deep-sea mining in recent years, has been accused of maintaining close ties with major mining groups, notably the Canadian company The Metals Company. This raises the question of the independence of an organisation that nonetheless steers the future of the ocean and must carry out its decision-making role with neutrality.
The draft mining code called for by a majority of its members will not be examined and approved until the 30th session of the ISA Assembly. In the meantime, the third United Nations Ocean Conference will be held in Nice in June 2025, on a joint initiative of the governments of France and Costa Rica.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.





