Home / Focus / Focus / France and Turkey: a lesson in diplomacy for reinventing French power

France and Turkey: a lesson in diplomacy for reinventing French power

By Hugo Da Costa – Geopolitical analyst *

In January 2025, the record of French foreign policy calls for urgent soul-searching. The decline in France’s international influence stands in contrast to the strategic rise of Turkey, an emerging middle power which, through pragmatic choices, is redefining its place on the global chessboard. Between divergent legacies and shared ambitions, these two trajectories offer food for thought on the strengths and weaknesses of French diplomacy. France’s gradual withdrawal from the world stage has become self-evident. Military failures, tensions in Africa, marginalisation in Europe: traditional tools such as its veto at the UN or nuclear deterrence are no longer enough. France, long seen as a great power, must now accept its status as a middle power.

Meanwhile, Turkey is emerging with a bold diplomatic model. Drawing on its Ottoman past and a proactive multilateral vision, it has established itself as an indispensable player in the Middle East, the Balkans and Africa. Its pragmatic approach, exemplified by its “rhythmic diplomacy”, allows it to play both sides: forging alliances with emerging countries while remaining a key partner of NATO and Europe. France and Turkey share a long-standing desire for strategic autonomy. Their paths diverge, however, when it comes to turning that ambition into lasting influence. Turkey relies on political stability and a clear strategy, embodied by the AKP for two decades. France, by contrast, undermined by ideological swings between governments and a loss of vision, is struggling to hold a steady course.

Turkish diplomacy draws on a plural identity, combining Kemalist and Ottoman legacies. It acts as a mediator, at once a Janus facing the West and a champion of the oppressed in the Middle East. This flexibility contrasts with France’s rigid and often paternalistic image, particularly in Africa and the Levant, where its colonial past is catching up with it.

Rethinking the French model

To regain its influence, France must make a strategic shift. This means redefining its regional and international autonomy. At European level, it can capitalise on its nuclear deterrent to take the lead in a common defence. Reindustrialisation and technological innovation are also crucial levers for strengthening its economic autonomy. Internationally, an overhaul of its relations, particularly with Africa, is imperative. Abandoning a paternalistic approach in favour of partnerships between equals could restore its image. Turkey, through its ability to find common ground with its interlocutors, shows the importance of a diplomacy based on trust and reciprocity.

France still has assets with which to reinvent itself. However, it must swiftly regain internal stability and a clear vision of its ambitions. Without this, it risks becoming bogged down in its current role as a hesitant middle power. Turkey, with its pragmatism and adaptability, offers valuable inspiration for navigating a changing world order. In short, the challenge for France is to turn its weaknesses into opportunities. This will require not only far-reaching reforms but also the courage to break with outdated models and embrace the dynamics of the 21st century.

AI-generated summary. Download the full analysis below

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.