Home / Opinion / From hatred of Trump to hatred of America: Davos as a breaking point

From hatred of Trump to hatred of America: Davos as a breaking point

By Alain Jourdan

There are moments in the history of international relations when an accumulation of weak signals suddenly turns into an open rupture. Davos 2026 now looks like one of those pivotal moments. Not as a mere economic forum, but as the symbolic place where a profound shift took place in the way the United States is viewed. What until then had been a targeted rejection of Donald Trump now seems to be sliding into a broader distrust of America itself.

For several years, Donald Trump has been the focus of growing hostility on the international stage. His brutal style, his aggressive rhetoric and his purely transactional conception of international relations have deeply offended his traditional partners. Until now, however, that hostility remained confined to him personally and to his administration. America, as a power and as a symbol, remained largely separate from this criticism. The events at Davos mark precisely the moment when that distinction began to blur.

The episodes that followed one another there acted as a trigger. Christine Lagarde walking out of a meeting with the Trump team, the US president’s repeated and often contemptuous attacks on Europeans, and the open questioning of historic alliances and of multilateralism caused far more than diplomatic unease. They gave rise to a collective realisation, particularly in Europe, of a profound change in America’s stance. At Davos, irritation gave way to genuine exasperation.

This shift is part of a broader unravelling of the American narrative built up over decades. For a long time, the United States enjoyed exceptional symbolic capital, fuelled as much by its diplomacy as by its cultural power. American cinema, in particular, shaped the image of an America embodying the side of good, defending freedom and order against chaos. That narrative, deeply rooted in the collective Western imagination, is now being seriously undermined.

Under Donald Trump, it is no longer merely a foreign policy that is being contested, but a civilisational stance that is being called into question. America no longer presents itself as the guarantor of a rules-based international order, but as a hegemonic power unabashedly embracing power politics, including towards its allies. This transformation profoundly blurs the image that the United States had patiently built up since the Second World War.

The Greenland episode illustrates this rupture in a particularly striking way. The pressure applied, the aggressive statements and the barely veiled threats have had a disastrous effect in Europe. They have shattered the notion that certain lines remained uncrossable in transatlantic relations. Here again, it is not only Donald Trump who is being called into question, but what he reveals about an America prepared to cast off all imperial restraint.

Davos thus marked the moment when Europe stopped playing for time. Muted diplomatic language gave way to a harsher clarity. The assumption that Trump is merely a passing interlude is no longer enough to reassure, because the damage already runs deep. A paradigm shift is under way in relations between Europe and the United States, and it would be an illusion to believe that a mere change of tone or of leadership will suffice to restore the status quo ante.

Even though signs of rejection of Donald Trump’s policies are now emerging in the United States, both in Congress and among a growing share of the population, doubt has taken hold. An American counter-movement may be in the making, and one must hope so. But even if a revival were to occur, it will force Europe to fundamentally rethink its relationship with its historic ally, its strategic dependencies, its defence choices and its political sovereignty.

With hindsight, Donald Trump will no doubt appear less as an anomaly than as a revealer. He will have brought to light deep-seated trends, long concealed by American soft power and by a universalist discourse that has now been weakened. What Davos confirmed is that the world, and Europe in particular, is no longer judging just one man, but a trajectory and a world view.

If America fails to bring about a moral, political and strategic revival, the shift will be inevitable. Distrust of Donald Trump could then turn into a lasting rejection of America itself, not out of ideology but out of disillusionment. This is no doubt one of the most consequential turning points for international relations in the decades to come.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.