Home / Focus / Focus / Guterres in Tianjin: a call into the void, symptom of a dying multilateralism

Guterres in Tianjin: a call into the void, symptom of a dying multilateralism

On 1 September 2025 in Tianjin, addressing the leaders of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO), António Guterres delivered a keynote speech setting out his agenda: ceasefires in Gaza and Ukraine, the protection of civilians from Sudan to Myanmar, reform of the global financial system, a renewed push on climate, and digital cooperation on AI. It was all there: the priorities, the figures, the method, and the invocation of “principled leadership”. And yet it all rang strangely hollow. Not because the objectives are open to question, but because the system’s chief architect – the UN – no longer has the means to match its ambitions, nor the unchallenged legitimacy to carry the “Global South” with it. Rarely has the contrast between the sweep of the exhortations and the weakness of the levers been so stark. UN Pressdppa.un.org

The backdrop: the SCO aspires to be a centre of gravity as the UN searches for its voice

The setting was hardly neutral. In Tianjin, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin presented the SCO as the template for a “multipolar” order, invoking “true multilateralism”, announcing financial initiatives (a development bank), infrastructure projects and technological cooperation, and floating the idea of freeing Eurasia from dollar-dominated channels. In this piece of political theatre, the UN was not the conductor but a guest of honour: respected, certainly, but not decisive. Guterres praised the SCO’s capacity to “shape a more peaceful future”, yet it was Beijing that set the political tempo. ReutersAP News

Fair appeals, but no takers

On Gaza, the call for an “immediate and permanent” ceasefire, the release of the hostages and safe humanitarian access is morally and legally unanswerable. It comes even as UN bodies continue to document massive harm to civilians and the collapse of basic systems. Yet these warnings are lost in the din of a war in which the key players – the United States, Israel, Egypt, Qatar, Iran and the Palestinian factions – do not share the same priorities, and in which the UN no longer has any credible leverage to apply, whether financial or political. The minimal “consensus”, already out of reach in the Security Council, is just as elusive in the capitals. The Guardian

On Ukraine, the call for a ceasefire “leading to a just, comprehensive and lasting peace” runs up against the logic of strategic attrition and the incompatibility of the warring parties’ aims. Here too, the UN carries weight only as a platform for speeches, not as a driving force. Recent mediation efforts have taken place outside its fold, at the initiative of pivotal states or through ad hoc formats. UN Press

When Washington cuts, New York withers

The budgetary argument is brutal but real: without money, there is no functioning multilateralism. Yet since 2024, Washington – historically the largest donor to the UN system – has piled up freezes, caps and targeted withdrawals. The US suspension of funding to UNRWA (first decided under the Biden administration in January 2024, then written into law by Congress in 2024) left a major gap that other donors have not filled. In 2025, political signals from the White House further fuelled a line of distrust towards certain UN agencies. The cumulative effect is clear: a chronic deficit, programmes at a standstill, and a Secretary-General reduced to exhorting rather than acting. Congress.govReutersJerusalem Center for Security and Foreign AffairsFDDThe White House

Credibility damaged in the eyes of the “Global South”

More corrosive still than the shortage of resources is the collapse of trust. For the past two years, Gaza has served, in the eyes of large sections of the “Global South”, to expose Western double standards. The charge – “what you condemn in Ukraine, you excuse in Gaza” – has taken root in public opinion and in foreign ministries that now make their choices according to regional interests rather than proclaimed norms. When the UN upholds those norms, it suffers by extension from the perceived alignment of its powerful sponsors. In these circumstances, the sermon delivered in Tianjin – peace, international law, reform – seems out of step with the reality of an organisation suspected of impotence and of being Western-centric. The WireThe GuardianODI: Think changeAl Jazeera

Reform: rhetoric versus geopolitics

Guterres is right: the world of 2025 is not the world of 1945. Giving emerging economies a greater voice and more rights in the IFIs (the IMF and the World Bank) or putting climate finance on a stable, predictable footing are no longer options but prerequisites. Except that these reforms require the consent of those who would lose relative power – and a willingness to make mutual concessions. Neither Washington nor Beijing, neither Brussels nor New Delhi seems ready to pay the political price of a substantive compromise. The result: a host of competing “initiatives”, but little common architecture. The SCO is offering its own grammar (a bank, platforms, corridors, AI), as are the BRICS, while the UN tries to bring it all together without the resources to lead. AP NewsReuters

Climate and AI: unequal responsibilities… and unequal coffers

Asking the G20 – 80% of emissions – to “lead by example” makes sense. But the demand runs aground on budgets and electoral cycles. The US$1.3 trillion a year for climate by 2030? Distant, fragmented, contentious. The UN mechanisms on AI? A “common forum” is useful, but most standards will come from regulators with deep markets (the EU, the United States, China) and from industry coalitions. Here again, the UN sets the framework; others decide. UN Press

Verdict

In Tianjin, António Guterres delivered the speech a secretary-general is expected to deliver. But the international stage responded with a polite shrug. Caught between austerity imposed by its largest donor, systemic competition from parallel architectures led by China and Russia, and Western moral credibility tarnished in the eyes of the “Global South”, the UN talks of principles while states talk of power. As long as the gap between the multilateral promise and budgetary and political reality remains this wide, appeals from New York will go on echoing… into the void. ReutersAP NewsThe White HouseJerusalem Center for Security and Foreign AffairsThe Wire

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.