By Jacques O’Keefe, Vice-President of the Cercle Canadien Francophone d’Analyse Géostratégique

During his 2024 presidential campaign, Donald Trump repeatedly declared that “tariff” was the most beautiful word in the dictionary and that he was a great admirer of President McKinley. McKinley, although an isolationist during his first term, when he imposed restrictive tariffs to protect American industry, turned out instead to be a globalist during his second term, when he used reciprocal tariffs to open international markets to American goods.
Once elected, Trump also declared that, as soon as he took office, he would impose tariffs of 25% on Canadian goods and 10% on energy from Canada. And this despite the fact that, during his first term, he had signed a renewed free trade agreement with Canada and Mexico. What is Trump’s signature worth? His justifications : in his view, Canada was not securing its border sufficiently to stop fentanyl entering the United States, and Canada exports more to the United States than it imports from it. In an unusual development in Canada–US relations : the Canadian Prime Minister, accompanied by several of his key ministers and advisers, travelled to Florida to meet the President-elect before he had even been sworn in, in an attempt to make him see reason and calm things down before he took office. They were told by Trump that Canada would be much better off if it became the 51st state of the United States. Is this the resurrection of the notion of Manifest Destiny?

Canada has announced measures to tighten its borders, even though, according to US Customs and Border Protection’s own figures, only about 1% of the fentanyl it intercepts passes through Canada. The Canadian federal and provincial governments also made representations to the US authorities to stress that Canada buys more from the United States than any other country, and that if the United States imports slightly more from Canada than Canada imports from the United States, it is because Canada is its main energy supplier. The vast majority of Canadian crude oil is sold to the United States, at a discount to the international market price, to be refined there and sold at a profit. Former Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chrétien recently remarked that, were it not for electricity from Hydro-Québec, Trump would have to climb the stairs of his tower in New York on foot, by candlelight. The imposition of tariffs on Canadian goods and energy has been postponed until early March.
In mid-February, Trump announced 25% tariffs on steel and aluminium from all countries, Canada included. The vast majority of aluminium imported into the United States comes from Canada, and producing it requires large amounts of cheap electricity. Is this the end of a highly privileged trading relationship dating back at least to the Second World War? Watch this space…
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






