
Today’s meeting in Geneva between American and Ukrainian officials is being hailed as a triumphant “return” of International Geneva. But this piece of stagecraft masks a far more troubling reality: the decisive talks on the future of the war are not being held in Geneva — they are taking place in Abu Dhabi, away from prying eyes, between Russians and Americans, face to face. And, above all, without those most directly affected.
This bilateral face-off, outside any multilateral framework, shows just how far the international order that Geneva symbolised is crumbling. Institutions are bypassed, inclusiveness is no longer sought, and the basic principle that peace must involve those who will pay its price is no longer respected. The great powers decide among themselves, as if Ukraine were merely a file rather than a people.
Geneva, a city built on the conviction that peace is forged in transparency and under the aegis of international law, has been reduced to a backdrop. Here there is no UN process, no collective responsibility, no institutional legitimacy. While symbolic meetings are staged on the shores of Lake Geneva, the real discussions — those concerning the front lines, security guarantees and the territorial future — are being held in secret in the Emirates, in a format that sidesteps everything Geneva has embodied for a century.
That is the legacy of Trumpian diplomacy: a transactional, closed diplomacy in which the powerful cut deals among themselves and places steeped in meaning — such as Geneva — are turned into showcases. Switzerland, far from being an actor, is now content merely to play host. It is no longer a mediator; it is a hotelier.
The paradox is a cruel one: those who rejoice at seeing Geneva “back” are in fact endorsing its eclipse. The city no longer carries any weight in matters of peace; it serves merely to dress up a process that is unfolding elsewhere, with no multilateral framework, no transparency and none of the parties directly concerned. If Ukraine’s future is being negotiated between Washington and Moscow in Abu Dhabi, that is a pure and simple circumvention of everything Geneva stands for.
At this rate, Geneva will no longer be a centre of decision-making but a mere stopover — a diplomatic hôtel de passe, a house of ill repute — while the real decisions are taken elsewhere, between powers, in contempt of the law and of peoples.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






