The images of the tense exchange between Volodymyr Zelensky, Donald Trump and his vice-president, JD Vance, have now passed into history. They have set off an avalanche of reactions and commentary. One thing is certain: the United States has not emerged from this episode with its standing enhanced. America no longer inspires dreams.

For decades, Hollywood sold us a polished, glossed-over image of the American way of life and of an America that championed freedom. For Europeans, the awakening is a painful one. Through the voice of Donald Trump, America is demanding what it is owed: a bill with all taxes included, plus a reminder about the arrears. Spaghetti westerns were often mocked, yet they doubtless offered a more realistic vision of America than the films of John Ford. The character played by Henry Fonda in Once Upon a Time in the West turns out to be far closer to reality than those played by John Wayne. Trump is a spaghetti-western character. We may take comfort in remembering that, in those films, the villain always comes to a bad end. But in the meantime, he is the one calling the shots.
The list of figures to whom Trump can be compared is a long one: the Joker in Batman, a mob boss in Goodfellas… Plenty to keep leader writers busy. But if we want to go further, this episode must be placed in the long sweep of history. Admittedly, Donald Trump has supporters even on the Old Continent, some of whom believe the system must be “blown to pieces”. They are the useful idiots. History will judge them harshly, for the indefensible cannot be defended. And there is no need to read tea leaves to predict the crash of this America. Perhaps we have already witnessed it. For what we have seen is a live collapse of American values. A collapse whose consequences could prove far more profound than those of the fall of the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center.
Calling the Atlantic Alliance into question to the very end would have colossal implications. This alliance rests on a foundation of values that other alliances, founded solely on economic interests, could never replace. Trump’s America is embarking on a path that could ultimately lead it to break with democratic principles. Yet that is simply not the direction of history.
The period we are living through is destabilising and, in many respects, frightening. But it is also a time of appointments with destiny. Churchill and De Gaulle emerged out of the darkness. Peoples took their destiny back into their own hands when all seemed lost. History, always, ends up putting things back in their rightful place.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






