Home / Focus / Focus / Children without a home port: the legal challenges of births in the Mediterranean Sea

Children without a home port: the legal challenges of births in the Mediterranean Sea

Observatoire Géostratégique de Genève
Dina Stéphanie RANAIVOSOA
Geopolitical analyst intern


Introduction


Repeated migration across the Mediterranean exposes certain groups to extreme hardship, particularly women on the verge of giving birth and young children. One of the most alarming phenomena remains the birth of children aboard rescue vessels, in makeshift camps or during perilous sea crossings. These births take place outside any formal administrative framework, depriving newborns of official registration, a recognised nationality and immediate access to their fundamental rights. Such a situation poses a major challenge under international law, particularly with regard to guaranteeing their legal protection from the moment they are born. This article sets out to analyse the legal and human implications of these births in transit, identifying existing gaps in the legal framework and exploring the levers that international law can bring to bear in response.
I. Born “in transit”: context and realities

The phenomenon of births along migration routes is a direct result of persistent protracted crises in the Middle East, Africa and South Asia, as well as the gradual closure of legal migration routes to Europe. Faced with armed conflict, persecution or extreme poverty, many pregnant women find themselves forced to undertake perilous Mediterranean crossings in haste, in the hope of a safer future for themselves and their children. As a result, several hundred children are born every year during these crossings. According to data from the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), children account for 16.7% of the 69,599 refugees and migrants who have taken the Central Mediterranean migration route since January 2023, or around 11,600 children.

Births on board rescue ships – such as those chartered by humanitarian organisations like SOS Méditerranée or Médecins Sans Frontières – raise considerable logistical and medical challenges. The lack of suitable medical equipment, deteriorating sanitary conditions and the impossibility of providing adequate neonatal follow-up pose major risks to the health of mothers and newborns. On land, too, in camps such as Moria (Greece) or Zarzis (Tunisia), facilities remain largely inadequate to guarantee safe births.


II. The shipwreck of international law: the risk of statelessness and invisibility

Beyond the immediate humanitarian challenges, births at sea raise significant legal questions. To which state should a child born on the high seas, beyond any territorial sovereignty, be attached? What nationality regime applies to a child who comes into the world on board a vessel chartered by a non-governmental organisation and flying the flag of a third state?

Two fundamental principles traditionally govern the attribution of nationality: jus soli, the right of the soil, and jus sanguinis, the right of blood. In a maritime context, however, applying these principles becomes more complex: under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982), a ship is legally treated as part of the territory of the state whose flag it flies. In theory, therefore – to take one example – a child born on board a French ship could be registered with the French authorities. In practice, such recognition is neither automatic nor systematic, particularly in the case of humanitarian rescue missions operated by NGOs.

Furthermore, two international legal instruments explicitly govern rights relating to birth and nationality. The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC, 1989), ratified by almost every UN member state, affirms in Article 7 the right of every child to be registered immediately after birth, to have a name and a nationality and, as far as possible, to know and be cared for by his or her parents . Likewise, the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness requires signatory states to prevent statelessness . Indeed, beyond individual rights, the lack of effective registration mechanisms also undermines international protection efforts and the application of measures for family reunification, legal guardianship or even asylum.

III. A study of miraculous rescues: between humanitarian miracle and geopolitical failure


In the absence of precise global data, the few available accounts suggest that at least 36 children were born aboard humanitarian vessels in the Mediterranean in 2018, six of them aboard the Aquarius, a ship belonging to SOS Méditerranée and Médecins Sans Frontières .


More recently, on 17 August 2024, a group of 36 Afghan refugees, including a 50-day-old baby named Ionas, was rescued on the Greek island of Tilos after three days in extreme conditions. Lacking any resources, his parents had been forced to use seawater in an attempt to feed him. The tragedy, reported by international media such as Le Monde and The Guardian, deeply moved public opinion and sparked a wave of outrage within civil society. Several humanitarian organisations condemned the persistent inaction of the European authorities in the face of the suffering of the most vulnerable migrants.


In the face of this media pressure, some states, such as Germany and the Netherlands, announced a temporary increase in their humanitarian aid in the Mediterranean. Nevertheless, no common European policy has emerged to provide a legal and humanitarian framework for these births at sea or along migration routes. This lack of institutional coordination highlights the persistent fragmentation of the European Union on migration governance. While countries of first entry, such as Greece and Italy, are calling for greater solidarity, others, notably Hungary and Poland, continue to favour strictly security-based and unilateral approaches. This patchwork of national responses helps to sustain genuine legal “grey areas” in which the fundamental rights of children born in transit are not fully guaranteed.


Thus, the European Union’s adoption of the Pact on Migration and Asylum in 2024 was not enough to establish a common approach to protecting children born during migration. Persistent disagreements between member states, notably over the sharing of reception responsibilities, continue to hold back any concrete progress. In countries of departure or transit such as Libya and Tunisia, reception conditions for migrants remain alarming, with documented cases of violence, denial of healthcare and arbitrary detention. In this context, children remain largely on the margins of existing protection frameworks, despite the proliferation of national and regional initiatives. It therefore appears essential to examine how international law can be harnessed, strengthened or adapted to guarantee these children recognition and protection from birth.


IV. The response of international law: the tools available and the outlook
Several international legal instruments – such as the three conventions mentioned above – should, in theory, provide a solid basis for remedying this situation. However, their effectiveness remains uneven, particularly when births occur in atypical settings where administrative oversight is often non-existent or deficient. Possible solutions do exist. Three of them will be highlighted here by way of illustration:


1) Putting births during migration on the agenda of international conferences
The first observation is that this issue is conspicuously absent from the major conferences on migration and children’s rights. Yet placing it explicitly on the agenda of bodies such as the Global Forum on Migration and Development (GFMD), the International Conferences on Population (UNFPA) or the United Nations Summits for Refugees and Migrants could trigger political and operational recognition of the problem.


2) Strengthening the mandate of UN agencies on civil registration in the context of migration
A formal expansion of the mandate of UNHCR or UNICEF, to include coordinating birth registration in the context of migration, would be a concrete response to the current gap between humanitarian action and administrative recognition. Such a change would require dedicated resources, stronger partnerships with states, and an adaptation of the legal frameworks governing their operations.


3) Formalise NGO–state protocols for registering births at sea
Finally, stronger cooperation between states, international organisations and NGOs is essential to prevent these children from being condemned to a life of statelessness and marginalisation. This cooperation would be governed by specific protocols, such as those for registering births on board vessels. These protocols would allow NGOs to report births securely, with legal recognition granted by states after the fact.

Conclusion
The case of children born at sea or along migration routes is emblematic of the current limits of global migration governance. In this lawless zone, their very existence runs up against the proclaimed principles of international law. Deprived of legal recognition, administrative protection and, at times, any legal identity whatsoever, these children embody a threefold vulnerability: legal, social and political. Their fate implicitly calls into question the international community’s ability to deliver on the commitments it proclaims. Recognition of the right to a legal identity from birth cannot remain an abstract principle; it demands concerted, lasting responses that are built into today’s geopolitical realities. Making international law an effective lever for protecting these children means affirming that, even on the move and even in exile, human dignity cannot be suspended.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.