Home / Analysis / Will Orbán’s spectre haunt Europe for years to come? Hungarians may not be so wrong

Will Orbán’s spectre haunt Europe for years to come? Hungarians may not be so wrong

After 16 years in power, Viktor Orban is stepping down as prime minister following his election defeat. Image created with AI.

In Hungary, a democratic election has brought to an end sixteen years of almost uninterrupted rule by a leader whom many in Europe have consistently labelled as anti-democratic. On the night of the vote, the European left celebrated what it saw as a liberation. Yet day by day, disillusion has set in, as the new Prime Minister, Péter Magyar, may not be quite the great humanist saviour he claimed to be during the campaign. Such a radical turnaround in less than two years, given that he was once close to the former prime minister, should have raised some suspicions.

Viktor Orbán’s Hungary was undoubtedly illiberal, but not strictly anti-democratic, despite very real excesses that grew steadily worse as power wore on. And yet Orbán left office without contesting the result, conceding defeat and congratulating his opponent, Péter Magyar, a formerly well-regarded diplomat at Hungary’s Permanent Representation in Brussels and now head of government. A man, then, from the ousted prime minister’s own camp, and the ex-husband of Judit Varga, who served as Minister of Justice under Orbán from 2019 to 2023, the year of their divorce. As recently as the end of 2023, Magyar was still at the heart of the system, and his wife one of the regime’s central figures. But never mind: the sentimental European left must not be disturbed.

This starting point ought to have encouraged a degree of caution in the hasty analyses that proliferated upon the arrival of this supposed harbinger of spring. For while Orbán, long nicknamed “Viktator” by his critics, has left power, this does not mean that what he embodied has disappeared, nor even that European societies have profoundly rejected it. Quite the opposite. What he represented for more than a decade has taken root in the continent’s political landscape.

For more than fifteen years, Orbán was not merely a provocative and radical leader. He was a symptom. A manifestation of a deep European malaise, born of the 2008 financial crisis, amplified by the 2015 migration crisis, and fed ever since by a succession of economic, identity and geopolitical shocks. In Budapest, this malaise found blunt, unapologetic and theorised expression. Elsewhere, it has spread more subtly, but just as durably.

Much has been said about the “Orbánisation” of Europe as an aberration. That was a mistake. It was not an isolated case on the old continent, but rather a structural trend. A way of governing at odds with common rules while remaining within the system to reap its benefits. Orbán did not invent this reflex; he radicalised it. And that is precisely why his defeat does not fundamentally change the situation.

Today’s Europe is full of governments that have learnt the lesson. Not that of head-on confrontation, but of calibration. Less provocation, more calculation. Less overt rupture, more strategic ambiguity. Where Orbán confronted Brussels directly, others prefer to negotiate, circumvent or slow things down. The result is often similar, but the method is more effective, more acceptable and therefore more durable.

The fall of the “lider magyaro”

In this regard, the example of Giorgia Meloni in Italy over the past three years is telling. Having come to power with an image of rupture, she quickly adopted a pragmatic stance: pro-European in her rhetoric, firm on national interests, and skilful in leveraging European mechanisms without setting herself in direct opposition. A kind of rationalised Orbánism. Less spectacular, but potentially more influential. While her economic record is still taking shape, given how far Italy had to recover, she continues to face constant criticism from those within the European Union who fear her. Otherwise, she would be met with indifference. Instead, she has put Italy back at the heart of the continent’s geopolitical dynamics.

This shift, far from being an exception, reveals a great deal about how Europe is evolving. The European Union is no longer openly contested. It is now being reshaped from within by a logic of selective sovereignty. Membership is accepted, but on condition that its margins are redefined. Rules are respected, but interpreted. Cooperation continues, but without naivety. This hybrid Europe is precisely the ground on which Orbán’s legacy is likely to thrive.

One essential question remains: why did he fall? Certainly not for the reasons some would like to highlight. It was neither his confrontational relationship with Brussels nor his sovereigntist rhetoric that brought him down. The answer lies elsewhere, primarily in the economy rather than in rights violations. It was his inability, over time, to meet the concrete expectations of part of the population. Governing through confrontation may help one seize power, but it is not enough to deliver lasting prosperity, social stability and credible prospects.

That is the limit that ultimately surfaced. Not the failure of a narrative, but of results. And that is precisely what other European leaders have grasped. They hold on to the political markers that resonate with their voters while taking care not to become trapped in a permanent logic of obstruction. Yet the economic hurdle is becoming ever harder to clear, for radical and moderate leaders alike.

The war in Ukraine has, on the surface, tightened European ranks. It has reduced the most visible margins of manoeuvre, particularly on energy and strategic issues. But it has not erased deeper reflexes. The temptation of national calculation, targeted protection, and opportunistic positioning remains. It is simply expressed in a more subdued manner.

Therein lies the real misunderstanding. The European Union believes it has turned the page. In reality, it has merely moved on to a new chapter. The underlying causes that fuelled Orbán’s rise remain: a sense of decline, territorial divides and a perceived loss of control over economic, migration and cultural issues. As long as these dynamics persist, they will continue to produce similar political responses.

Orbán’s defeat, therefore, settles nothing, despite what many enthusiastic Europhiles have been trying to suggest in recent days. It merely sweeps the dust under the rug for a while. The fall of the “lider magyaro” (magyar meaning Hungarian) opens a new phase, more discreet, more complex, less visible, but undoubtedly more turbulent beneath the surface. The era may no longer be one of openly divisive figures, but of leaders capable of combining European loyalty with national assertion, integration with power politics, while ultimately pursuing similar objectives.

A period of sustained turbulence in Europe

In this sense, Europe is entering a period of sustained turbulence. Less spectacular, but more strategic. “Orbánisation” did not die with Orbán. It has changed form. And that is precisely why it is likely to endure. The first strong statements by Péter Magyar upon leaving the Sándor Palace in Budapest, the presidential residence, set the tone: President Tamás Sulyok must go. The purge of the entire Orbán system and those who contributed to it has begun. At a press conference, Magyar emphasised institutionalised corruption under the former prime minister, the importance of relations with the European Union, and… immigration.

And here, the European left is already beginning to regret its enthusiasm. Magyar remains tough on the issue, shaped both by Hungary’s political legacy and by an electorate that remains deeply conservative. In September 2024, while already in opposition, he accused the government of bringing in 60,000 economic migrants from Asia each year and of prioritising multinational profits over the security and living standards of Hungarians. At the time, he even cited the concrete case of the rural region of Vitnyéd in western Hungary. His argument against Orbán’s supposed betrayal of the anti-immigration pact was that it drove down property prices and fuelled anxiety among residents unaccustomed to welcoming foreigners. Since then, Magyar has made a string of shock announcements: the temporary suspension of public television (in the name of purging it of the previous regime’s influence), a halt to programmes importing non-EU workers, and a cautious, partial reconciliation with Europe, particularly on Ukraine. So be it.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.