Abdoulahi Attayoub
The central Sahel, which mainly covers Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger, is a strategic region of West Africa marked by great ethnocultural diversity. For decades, the region has been beset by serious crises of governance, reflected in political instability and growing distrust among certain communities towards the authorities and the elites who have inherited political power since independence.
Cultural diversity, and the questions of political governance it raises, remain a blind spot in the strategies considered so far to overcome insecurity and chronic instability in the countries concerned. In this analysis, we will examine how the mismanagement of ethnocultural diversity weighs heavily on the geopolitics of the central Sahel, shedding light on relations between the region’s peoples, the latent conflicts that sometimes set them against one another, and the responses of states and the international community.

A great diversity of peoples
When the colonial period came to an end, France handed political power and the running of the newly independent states to elites carefully chosen from certain ethnic communities. These elites consequently built national projects around identity and cultural reference points that left little room for other communities, some of which were ignored outright or even fought against. The most telling example is undoubtedly what has come to be known as “the Tuareg question” in Niger and, above all, in Mali. This community had already shown its refusal to accept the fait accompli of the exclusion to which it had been subjected by the French colonial administration. Its traditional territory, which makes up the greater part of the new states’ land, thus slipped from its grasp.
“Nomadic” communities, for example, which practise extensive livestock farming, thus find themselves competing with farmers from sedentary communities, generating tensions over the management of agropastoral resources. Conflicts over the control of these resources, notably land and water, are intensifying in a context of climate change, with droughts and desertification having exacerbated them. These recurring tensions often turn into intercommunal conflicts, sometimes exploited by states that arm certain communities against others deemed resistant to the established order.
State failure, the consequence of an ill-suited institutional architecture
Today, the failure of the state in these countries and the failure of their elites to build models of governance that reflect sociocultural realities go at least some way to explaining the inroads made by new political ideologies and the rise of ethnocentrism, which objectively threaten the organisational structures inherited from the colonial administration. The AES (Alliance of Sahel States) project, launched in haste by the three countries of the central Sahel to deal with the crisis with ECOWAS (the Economic Community of West African States) that followed the series of coups d’état, perfectly illustrates the risk of a deadlock that could dash any hope of a swift return to stability founded, at last, on governance better suited to the human realities of these Sahelo-Saharan regions.
Jihadist opportunism
The failure of the state is also evident in its near-total absence from certain areas far from the centre, which are regarded as peripheries and have remained under-administered since independence. While this situation can be explained in part by sheer geographical size, particularly in Niger and Mali, its main cause is the concentration of power around the capitals and, therefore, the communities that surround them. The administrative vacuum and the frustrations born of the sense of abandonment felt by some populations are now being conveniently filled by what non-state actors have to offer, including local militias and jihadist groups. The Fulani, for example, are frequently associated with jihadist movements because of their strong presence among their recruits. This feeds dangerous stereotypes and leads to stigmatisation among other communities, which end up regarding the Fulani as a threat.
The blindness of the international community
Having often confined itself to ensuring the stability of these countries, sometimes in disregard of the most basic rules of human rights and international law, the international community has focused its support on military matters. To build a peaceful future and overcome chronic instability, the international community should pay closer attention to the quality of the support it offers these countries, in particular by ensuring that the development policies and projects in which it is a partner are inclusive.
Outlook: inclusive governance and the rebuilding of states
The state can only be viable and fulfil its functions if it meets citizens’ expectations and is seen as impartial and protective. Shared national narratives are the only path towards building truly inclusive nations that would allow these countries to focus their energy on more realistic development policies. Overly centralised political systems have shown their limits, and the need for a different form of organisation for these states is becoming an imperative on which their survival of the current crisis will depend. The post-colonial state architecture in the Sahel has failed to demonstrate that it can foster the emergence of an inclusive governance pact. Genuine regionalisation would allow citizens to reconnect with a territory that matches their historical, cultural and psychological points of reference, and thereby defuse resentment towards the state and the communities generally associated with it.
Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger will need to make efforts to ensure better representation of the various ethnic communities in decision-making processes. Development and security policies will also have to be tailored to local realities, so that no community comes to feel marginalised. Strengthening the presence of the state in a positive way, through economic development, education and the promotion of social justice, could help to restore people’s trust in institutions. A fair justice system and intercultural dialogue programmes can also reduce perceptions of discrimination and ease tensions.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






