Home / Opinion / Europe trapped by America’s strategic realignment

Europe trapped by America’s strategic realignment

By Anas Abdoun, Senior Analyst Africa & Middle-East at Stratas Advisors

From the very first days of the war in Ukraine, Europe saw its foreign policy upended by American strategy and was pushed into an almost partisan stance. Washington wasted no time in convincing European leaders that a military victory for Kyiv was not only possible but desirable, ruling out from the outset the option of active diplomacy, even though Europeans had historically favoured that approach in their neighbourhood. In this context, the European voice, once inclined towards moderation and dialogue, has been effaced, reduced to a mere extension of the White House’s strategic objectives.

The European position and American influence

The sanctions imposed on Russia were anything but a diplomatic attempt to keep channels of negotiation open. Quite the opposite: they struck indiscriminately not only at the regime but also at the Russian economy and at figures deemed to represent the Kremlin, whether they were close to it or merely suspected of being so. The boycott even extended to cultural and sporting events, as well as to commercial flights, reinforcing the perception of a Europe embarking on a policy of wholesale rejection, if not Russophobia. Rather than acting as a bulwark against escalation, Europe thus appeared to be entering into head-on confrontation, breaking once and for all with its tradition as a mediator in its dealings with Russia.

This stance was compounded by an unprecedented economic hardening. Europeans not only restricted exports of goods to Russia but also drastically cut their imports, depriving their industries of essential raw materials. Behind this strategy, one can discern as much American pressure as European idealism in the form of unconditional support for Ukraine, seen as an unavoidable moral position. The destruction of the Nord Stream gas pipeline, unofficially attributed to the United States, finished locking down Europe’s energy options, sealing a geopolitical rift that is now all but irreparable. Meanwhile, Washington continues to buy Russian uranium, glaring proof that American strategic choices never sacrifice the country’s own economic interests on the altar of morality. Europe has thus found itself forced to take sides in a conflict which, beyond the values on display, is part of a complex dynamic in which American pragmatism always wins out over slogans of solidarity.

 Economic consequences and gas dependence

Faced with the collapse of its energy partnership with Russia, Europe found itself deeply vulnerable, exposed to the immediate effects of its dependence. This abrupt rupture drove European countries to seek emergency alternatives to avert a major energy crisis, but the price to be paid proved far heavier than expected. By replacing Russian natural gas with American liquefied natural gas (LNG), Europe swapped an abundant and relatively cheap resource for a costlier and less certain substitute. For the United States, this transition was a golden opportunity: by forcing their shale LNG onto the European market, they managed to fill the gap left by Russia while tightening their grip on Europe’s energy supply.

The cost of this dependence on gas imported from across the Atlantic has had a snowball effect on the European economy as a whole. Germany, once the continent’s industrial engine, found itself on the front line. Its model, built on low-cost production and formidable competitiveness, could no longer withstand the surge in energy costs. The country, which once boasted a record trade surplus of more than €100 billion, is now in deficit for the first time in decades and is mired in a lingering recession. The consequences go well beyond a mere slowdown in growth: the entire German economic model, and by extension the European one, is faltering, weakened by its inability to access energy at a competitive cost.

Against this fragile backdrop, the United States extended its lead by adopting the Inflation Reduction Act, an economic policy that threw the doors wide open to economic dumping that has been particularly damaging for Europe. Through tax incentives and direct support, the law not only enabled the United States to boost its own industrial output but also drew in European companies tempted to relocate across the Atlantic to escape mounting energy and financial pressures in Europe. As strategic sectors shift elsewhere, Europe faces the prospect of gradual deindustrialisation, in which its global economic role is shrinking, jeopardising decades of patiently built industrial leadership.

Europe, once a pioneer in productivity and competitiveness, thus finds itself caught in a downward spiral in which its energy and industrial autonomy is crumbling. While America strengthens its position, Europe appears to be sinking into a structural crisis, weakened by choices that, in the name of morality, have compromised its economic survival.

Impact of Donald Trump’s re-election

 Donald Trump’s re-election could abruptly redraw the international balance of power, particularly with regard to the conflict in Ukraine. Trump, whose pragmatic and isolationist approach to foreign policy is well known, could impose a negotiated settlement, driven by his refusal to fund a costly war which, in his view, does not serve the vital interests of the United States. Such a stance would herald a major U-turn: as Ukraine’s leading supplier of arms and financial support, Washington wields decisive influence, and an American withdrawal would deprive Kyiv of essential resources, forcing it to accept the terms of a peace deal dictated by the United States.

In addition, President Trump has also announced his intention to step up protectionist measures, targeting industrial imports from Europe in particular. This agenda, built around a renewed trade war, could include tariffs of up to 50% on European products, threatening key industrial sectors such as cars, technology and manufactured goods.

For the United States, these protectionist measures serve a twofold purpose: to protect its domestic market and to attract economically struggling European companies, which would be encouraged to relocate their production to the United States to avoid prohibitive tariffs. The strategy, already set in motion by policies such as the Inflation Reduction Act, encourages European companies to leave a continent hit by high energy costs and recession and to set up in America, where they would benefit from a more favourable tax and energy environment.

Seen in this light, Europe finds itself in a delicate position. An early end to the Ukrainian conflict driven by Washington would leave it strategically isolated from Russia, without the energy resources critical to its industry, while remaining economically exposed to increasingly aggressive American protectionism. If Trump imposes trade barriers on European imports, European industries, already weakened by rising energy costs, would be doubly penalised, threatened with losing not only their competitiveness but also their access to the American market.

Far from simply marking the end of a conflict, then, Trump’s return could in fact plunge Europe into an unprecedented economic and industrial crisis. By imposing its rules and its tariffs, Washington would tighten its grip on an increasingly dependent Europe, limited in its strategic options and forced to choose between submitting to a protectionist American market and growing economic marginalisation.

A new world order unfavourable to Europe

To make matters worse, the way the world order is evolving does not play into Europeans’ hands. China, for its part, is pursuing its ambitions for global influence with strategic consistency, backed by a centralised model of governance that allows it to plan and invest in very long-term projects. Through initiatives such as the New Silk Road and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, Beijing is anchoring its economic and political presence in key regions, consolidating lasting partnerships without imposing on itself the ideological constraints faced by European governments. This long-term vision, structured and funded by colossal resources, is making China an increasingly indispensable global player, offering developing countries a cooperation option often perceived as more stable and less interventionist than that put forward by the Western powers.

Meanwhile, the countries of the Global South, whose populations and economies are growing rapidly, are redefining their alliances and ambitions. Emerging economies such as India, Brazil and Nigeria now demand to be treated as equals, seeking balanced and diversified relationships that break away from the old European spheres of influence. Other countries, particularly in Africa, are marking a turning point by distancing themselves from the former colonial powers to explore new strategic partnerships, notably with China and Russia, or South-South partnerships. France’s loss of influence in several African countries illustrates this broader movement of emancipation, in which former colonies favour multiple alliances and seek to break with their historical dependence on Europe. Taken together, these dynamics highlight an international order that is increasingly unfavourable to Europe, which is struggling to maintain its position in a multipolar world. Ultimately, Europe, weakened economically and politically, finds itself marginalised in a world where alliances are being redrawn around new poles of power whose new logic it struggles to decipher and over which it struggles to exert influence.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.