Home / International Geneva / [EXCLUSIVE] Geneva remains a pivotal venue for diplomacy and international negotiations

[EXCLUSIVE] Geneva remains a pivotal venue for diplomacy and international negotiations

Valued for his personal qualities, the Slovak diplomat Fedor Rosocha takes a sharp look at the international situation and the role of the UN in this particularly difficult context, in which the future of International Geneva as a centre of multilateral diplomacy is at stake.

Interview by Alain Jourdan

From 2017 to 2020, Fedor Rosocha was Director of the Department of the United Nations and International Organisations within the United Nations system. He was Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary – Permanent Representative of the Slovak Republic to the United Nations and other international organisations in Geneva from 2009 to 2017. Mr Rosocha was Director of the Department of Economic Diplomacy at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Slovakia from 2008 to 2009.

Ambassador Rosocha was also a member and Chair of the Consultative Group (2010–2011) and Vice-President (2011–2012) of the Human Rights Council in Geneva. He was President of the ECOSOC General Segment in Geneva (2011). From 2010 to 2017, Mr Rosocha was Head of Delegation for Slovakia’s periodic reports to CERD (Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination), CAT (Committee against Torture), CESCR (Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights) and the CRC (information office to the CRC), (Convention on the Rights of the Child), in Geneva.

He speaks English, Russian, French and Serbian.

La Tribune des Nations (LTDN): With your experience, what do you see as the first thing that must change for the United Nations to regain credibility? Should the workings of the Security Council be reformed, as Kofi Annan proposed? Or should we go even further?

Fedor Rosocha (FR) : There is no peace without development, there is no development without peace, and there is neither peace nor development without human rights. Kofi Annan’s words still resonate and remain as relevant as ever. In today’s world, challenges seem to be multiplying at an unprecedented pace. Realities are increasingly complex, yet a fundamental reorganisation of the UN reflecting these changes has yet to take place – even though the organisation celebrated its 80th anniversary next year.

Efforts towards a more fundamental repositioning of the UN were launched by the Secretary-General in his vision entitled “Our Common Agenda”. It sets out prospects for the next 25 years and builds on the progress already achieved in practice. The initial aim of the reform was to tackle sexual abuse in peacekeeping and to achieve gender parity in the UN’s senior management. The subsequent steps sought broader adjustments to the development, peace and security pillars, as well as to management as a whole.

Despite the ambition and appetite on the part of (some) UN members for a more disruptive transformation, comprehensive reform has not happened. Political disputes over the UN’s positioning and power have hampered any possibility of responding substantively to the organisation’s wider needs and making it more fit for purpose.

When the relevance and effectiveness of the United Nations are discussed, reform of the Security Council naturally springs to mind. Recent developments have shown that the SC is the least fit-for-purpose part of the UN, largely because of the widening ideological gulf between the P5. The UN SC, regarded as the world’s watchdog and moral compass, has failed to rise to the crises in Ukraine, Israel/Palestine, Sudan and elsewhere. Its most glaring institutional flaw is its outdated composition and very limited representation, which does not fully reflect geopolitical trends in today’s multipolar political order.

Nevertheless, it is important to note that fundamental overhauls of the Security Council (and of the United Nations as a whole, for that matter) take time to take root. We must bear in mind that all 193 UN member states have to engage and reach consensus on every aspect of the reform. So far, the negotiations are heading towards the lowest common denominator, and it is up to us – the member states collectively – to raise the level of ambition.

LTDN: The UN is currently facing a budget crisis that is forcing it to make savings. In Geneva, escalators and lifts have been switched off as part of the cuts imposed to keep within budget. In your view, what steps should be taken to make it run more efficiently and less expensively?

FR : Switching off escalators and lifts, suspending interpreters after 6 pm or restricting the use of rooms for negotiations are, of course, merely temporary measures that will bring no lasting change to the organisation’s overall financial health. We cannot treat a gunshot wound with a sticking plaster.

The main cause of the liquidity crises is no secret. The build-up of arrears leaves gaping holes in the regular budget and the peacekeeping budget, undermining financial predictability. On the one hand, we urge the UN’s leadership to be more efficient and to offer better value for money; on the other, we waste their time with the disrupted cash flows that management has to deal with every day. It is estimated that every year over the past decade, 40 to 50 states have failed to pay their assessed contributions in full or on time. The UN’s largest contributor is also its largest debtor, both in terms of mandatory contributions to the UN regular budget and in terms of peacekeeping operations. Other states are also lagging behind, including the second-largest contributor. Restrictive budgetary rules, which require every proposal to be submitted to the Fifth Committee for approval, leave no room for managerial flexibility.

The SG has made several proposals to improve the UN’s financial situation. Some measures are already being implemented in practice, such as the switch from semi-annual to annual budgeting and the centralisation of cash management for peacekeeping missions. Other suggestions include increasing annual contributions to the UN’s reserves and lowering the debt threshold beyond which states lose their vote in the General Assembly. At present, Article 19 of the Charter provides that “A Member of the United Nations which is in arrears in the payment of its financial contributions to the Organization shall have no vote in the General Assembly if the amount of its arrears equals or exceeds the amount of the contributions due from it for the preceding two full years”. These, or similar options, will need to be discussed.

LTDN: For some years now, Geneva no longer seems to be the place sought after by the whole world for negotiating peace and security. In your view, has Geneva lost some of its influence? And why?

FR: Geneva has always been an important and widely recognised centre for peace and security negotiations, and I believe it remains so. Even so, the deteriorating security environment, caused mainly by intensifying global competition and large-scale crises, notably Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, is weakening the disarmament and security architecture, which rests on a delicate balance between the post-Second World War arrangements on which Geneva’s institutions were built.

Despite this, Geneva remains a pivotal venue for international diplomacy and negotiations, particularly in the field of security. The city is still home to international institutions such as the Office for Disarmament Affairs and the Conference on Disarmament, and crucial multilateral agreements were born here, including the NPT, the CTBT, the Biological Weapons Convention, the Chemical Weapons Convention, the Anti-Personnel Mine Ban Convention and the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons. It is a long list of achievements that cannot be overlooked, and whose expertise can be put to good use when political will allows. 

LTDN: The Conference on Disarmament, which you chaired, has also stalled. For years its work has been blocked. The world has even embarked on a new arms race, in conventional but also nuclear weapons. How can this headlong rush be slowed or stopped?

FR: Unfortunately, negotiations on disarmament instruments at the Conference on Disarmament have been deadlocked for more than two decades. I am not optimistic that the situation will improve in the near future. Since 2017, when I had the privilege of presiding over the Conference during Slovakia’s rotating presidency, international security has steadily deteriorated. The dismantling of the arms control architecture reflects this, and the world is currently at the stage of military and nuclear build-up by certain states. Unfortunately, it is very difficult at present to make progress on nuclear disarmament. I think it is more realistic, and necessary, to focus on slowing the current negative trends. What is needed is greater compliance with existing treaties, greater transparency and intensified dialogue on the part of the nuclear-weapon states, as well as initiatives that could contribute to risk reduction and confidence-building.

LTDN: Today, diplomats seem powerless in the face of an escalation that has reignited regional conflicts amid a Cold War climate. Why are diplomats no longer able to put out the fires?

FR : I would not regard diplomacy as an ineffective or futile endeavour. Quite the contrary: today’s world needs more skilled diplomats, not fewer. The range of issues and challenges, as well as the number and type of non-state actors involved in diplomacy, has widened. Global relations have become a highly complex maze that can at times be difficult to navigate. Modern diplomacy is not led solely by government representatives, but includes multilateral organisations, NGOs, grassroots organisations and academics across a wide variety of fields. This calls for specialist knowledge and skills in addition to those of negotiating and concluding agreements. In other words, diplomats now have a great deal more to do.

Global challenges demand global solutions. No state can tackle phenomena such as climate change, cyberspace or outer space on its own, to name but a few. To return to your question about the UN’s standing, having a global platform for diplomatic endeavour is a fundamental prerequisite for the very existence of diplomacy, particularly in the light of today’s problems.

The UN is first and foremost an effective standard-setting body, supporting the monitoring and implementation of commitments negotiated by diplomats. The 2030 Agenda and its SDGs are one example, and today serve as a focal point for the international community. The UN has convening power and protects a diversity of voices in an increasingly shrinking space for civil society. The forthcoming Summit of the Future will be another opportunity for diplomats to direct their efforts towards a better future.

LTDN: What, in your view, are the major issues underlying all these crises? A clash of civilisations? A war over resources? Global warming and its consequences for migration? Demographics?

FR : All of the above. Also, the refusal of certain UN member states to respect the principles of the Charter of the United Nations. We need more trust and solidarity; their absence is one of the root causes of the current crises.

LTDN: What have your years in Geneva given you?

I have learnt two main lessons over my long and rewarding diplomatic career as an ambassador: 1) the act of listening – by which I mean active listening, when you try to connect deeply with your interlocutor’s message and understand where their position comes from. What he or she said, and also what he or she did not say. It is almost an art of reading people, which I consider an essential skill for diplomats. 2) Never stop learning – about cultures, societies, the arts, religions, politics. It enriches you not only as a professional, but also as a human being.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.