Home / Interview / “In Europe, we are facing a threat that did not exist in its current form”

“In Europe, we are facing a threat that did not exist in its current form”

On the eve of his visit to Geneva, where he is due to speak this Tuesday at the Institut Florimont at the invitation of the Société des membres de la Légion d’honneur (SMLH), Bernard Cazeneuve gave an interview to La Tribune des Nations. The former Minister of the Interior sets out his analysis of how the terrorist threat in Europe has evolved, of the new balances in international security, of the role of multilateralism and of the challenges facing the rule of law, while reaffirming the fundamental need to reconcile security and liberty over the long term.

Since the attacks of 2015 and 2016, how have you seen the nature of the terrorist threat in Europe evolve? Is it now more diffuse, more local or simply different?

The threat is no longer as intense, owing to the measures taken since 2014 by both individual states and the European Union to strengthen the resources of the security and intelligence services, through new legislation and increases in staffing and budgets. States are therefore better equipped to deal with the terrorist threat. In France in particular, the Intelligence Act of July 2015 strengthened the means of preventing the terrorist threat.

In 2014, French intelligence was governed by a law dating from 1991 — in other words, from an era with neither mobile phones nor the internet, whereas terrorists were preparing attacks using encrypted means of communication. Closer cooperation within the European Union — through the exchange of information made possible by the use of the Schengen Information System – the introduction of the PNR (Passenger Name Record), the reform of the Schengen Borders Code, and judicial and police cooperation within Eurojust and Europol — has made it possible to better coordinate the work of the various services responsible for counter-terrorism. Nevertheless, despite these efforts, the threat remains real today and could resurface at any moment. What has been set in motion must therefore continue, and vigilance must be maintained.

In your view, does jihadist terrorism remain the main threat to Europe, or should other forms of violent radicalisation now be given as much attention?

In Europe, we are first of all facing a threat that did not exist in its current form in 2014 and 2015: I am referring to the cyber threat and to the return of war to the European continent, notably on its eastern flank, in Ukraine. This situation raises many questions about our collective ability to preserve peace by guaranteeing a credible common security framework in Europe. We will not escape the rearmament of states and the strengthening of European defence cooperation within NATO, at a time when the transatlantic bond is being called into question by the Trump administration.

As for forms of violent radicalisation, the most significant today remains, in my view, the Islamist terrorist threat: scattered centres of activity persist around the world and could, at any moment, regain the capacity to send criminal commando units onto our soil, notably from Syria or Afghanistan. There is also a spread of terrorism across the Sahel belt, and we can see today the serious threats it poses to the future of certain countries, notably Mali. This overall context unquestionably represents a danger for Europe, which must therefore remain extremely vigilant and mobilised.

The Sahel remains a burning issue. What would it take today to stabilise the region and bring under control the groups that are once again thriving?

France intervened very swiftly in the Sahel to prevent Mali from falling into the hands of Islamists, which would have reduced the country to slavery and plunged its people into great suffering. It was therefore right to act in 2013. But France cannot do everything on its own and indefinitely. African states have taken part in the fight against terrorism in the Sahel. Chad, for example, played a particularly important role in the fight against Boko Haram. But France cannot act in Africa by remaining too long in theatres of operation where the baton must be passed to African multinational forces, backed by the UN.

Nearly 75 million pieces of information are exchanged each year within the European Union through the Schengen Information System

 You have often stressed European cooperation on intelligence. Has real progress been made over the past ten years, or are there still obstacles?

I believe that significant progress has been made over the past ten years in cooperation between intelligence services. This is due in particular to the development of tools such as the wanted persons file, the Schengen Information System (SIS) and the PNR, which allow information to be exchanged continuously between police and intelligence services. Nearly 75 million pieces of information are exchanged each year within the European Union through the Schengen Information System, an instrument provided for by the European treaties and essential to the centralisation and exchange of information between services. A great deal of progress has therefore been made in the context of the terrorist crisis to improve this cooperation and to make the action of states in preventing and combating terrorism far more effective than before.

In a city such as Geneva, a symbol of multilateralism, what role can international organisations play in preventing and combating terrorism?

Today we are witnessing the world entering a new era, marked by a weakening of the principles of international law and of the international order inherited from the end of the Second World War, of which the organisations based in Geneva are nonetheless the embodiment and the symbol. This decline is linked to the return of national ambitions and imperialisms, including within the free world, as the recent evolution of the United States shows. We are also seeing a decline in commitment to the principles of the rule of law.

Many political forces, including in democratic states, now believe that democracy could be stripped of the principles of the rule of law without undermining the universal values we share. In a world where imperialism is resurfacing, along with the sometimes predatory ambitions of economic, commercial and military powers, the role of multilateral organisations is therefore decisive. All the more so because there is no possibility of keeping the peace if force everywhere takes the place of law.:

Some non-terrorist criminal activities have helped to finance terrorist operations.

Can terrorism, organised crime and hybrid state strategies still be clearly distinguished, or have these boundaries become porous?

These boundaries have long been porous. We saw, particularly during the deadliest attacks of the 2014-2016 period, that there were close links between terrorist organisations and international crime. Some non-terrorist criminal activities have helped to finance terrorist operations. The mass killings committed in Europe were made possible by access to weapons, often recycled from the war in the Balkans and sold to terrorists by criminal arms-trafficking organisations.

That is why I pushed hard within the European Union for the adoption of a European directive to combat arms trafficking, which finally happened after the attacks on the Bataclan, the Stade de France and the café terraces. Likewise, closer cooperation within Eurojust and Europol has made it possible to fight these criminal and mafia networks effectively.

Drawing on your experience, what was the most difficult moment in managing the terrorist threat at the highest level of the state?

Every moment was difficult. The attacks, which claimed a great many victims, deeply traumatised the public and plunged the nation into mourning. Those were terrible times, both for the French people and for those who held responsibilities within the machinery of state. We were in a genuine race against time, constantly strengthening the budgetary and legislative resources available to the security and intelligence services, while upholding the principles of the rule of law. Each attack was experienced as a failure by those whose duty it was to protect the French people, and as an ordeal by the whole nation.

In your view, what mistakes must not be repeated in the coming years?

The governments that have led the countries of the European Union, and this is true of France, did their best, it seems to me, to combat terrorism. We very quickly understood the nature of Islamism: a totalitarian ideology, of which Muslims were the first victims, committing heinous crimes in order to impose a social order radically opposed to democratic principles.

We responded without naivety to fight and eradicate this ideology and the threat it carried within it. When I was Minister of the Interior, I was fortunate to act in a relatively consensual political climate, with political forces on both the right and the left showing a sense of responsibility in order to prevent the country from sliding into confrontation.

To conclude, what message would you give to young Europeans facing these challenges of security and freedom?

 I would tell them that nothing done in the name of security comes at the expense of freedom. Those who commit acts of terrorism are seeking precisely to push us into giving up our freedoms, because they know that doing so would create extreme tensions and weaken our ability to live together. Whatever trials lie ahead, we must always preserve the fine thread that binds freedom and security, in a shared ambition to preserve and deepen democracy, fraternity and respect for others. Security guarantees freedom, and freedom must remain the foremost concern of those responsible for ensuring the security of the French people, because the deeper purpose of security policies is to enable everyone to remain free.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.