The appointment of the former Iraqi President Barham Saleh to head the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) is bad news for Geneva and for Switzerland. It marks a diplomatic setback that is all the more keenly felt given that Bern had actively backed Christine Schraner Burgener, a former State Secretary and UN Special Envoy, whose profile was widely seen as one of the strongest to lead the UN agency through a period of severe turbulence.
Barham Saleh will succeed Italy’s Filippo Grandi in January, at a particularly critical juncture for UNHCR. The agency is grappling with a sharp drop in international funding and has had to cut more than a quarter of its workforce since the start of the year, some 5,000 posts. This unprecedented reduction is undermining its ability to respond to ever more numerous and complex migration crises, while fuelling a climate of deep uncertainty within the institution.
Against this backdrop, Switzerland had pinned its hopes on Christine Schraner Burgener, who is recognised for her diplomatic experience, her detailed knowledge of the UN system and her long-standing commitment to human rights. Her elimination is seen as a missed opportunity to place at the head of UNHCR a figure closely tied to Switzerland’s humanitarian tradition and to the spirit of International Geneva. It also highlights the limits of Swiss influence, despite the country’s important role as a host state and donor to the multilateral system.
Beyond the setback for Switzerland, the appointment of Barham Saleh raises questions about the direction being set for the agency. A former head of state and a respected political figure, he nonetheless inherits an organisation in turmoil, facing painful management choices and an urgent need for reform. At a time when UNHCR would need leadership seen as first and foremost technocratic and operational, this choice may appear out of step to many observers and humanitarian partners.
For Geneva, the stakes are also symbolic. UNHCR is one of the flagship institutions of International Geneva, and its leadership has a direct bearing on the city’s standing as the world’s humanitarian capital. Failing to see a Swiss-backed candidate emerge, just as competition between international hubs is intensifying, weakens Geneva’s position on the multilateral stage.
Finally, this appointment comes at a delicate moment for the credibility of the international humanitarian system. With needs soaring and resources shrinking, the choice of the new High Commissioner could have embodied a strong response to the crisis, founded on continuity, expertise and the ability to restore trust. For Switzerland and for Geneva, the episode leaves a bitter taste and is a reminder that, even at the heart of the humanitarian world, political balances continue to weigh heavily on decisions.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






