Home / Opinion / Middle powers and multipolarity: towards a new global balance

Middle powers and multipolarity: towards a new global balance

By Rohan Sant, back from Astana

In the heart of Europe, Switzerland has long played the role of “middle power” on the international stage. As geopolitical stakes shift towards the Far East, several countries are positioning themselves in this niche, signalling a desire to act as mediators between the major blocs that are now redrawing the global balance of power. On 16 and 17 October, Astana hosted a forum that set out to define the role of these middle powers and their capacity for action.

As the world shifts from a unipolar system to a multipolar order, a group of so-called “intermediate” nations is emerging. These “middle powers” could play a vital role in maintaining global stability in the years ahead. With less military and economic might than the superpowers, they have set themselves the tasks of mediating conflicts, strengthening regional stability and promoting international cooperation in fields ranging from technology to diplomacy. These, at any rate, are some of the conclusions reached by the hundred or so specialists from around twenty countries (the United States, Russia, China, all the Central Asian countries, India, Pakistan, France, Hungary, South Korea, Mongolia, Georgia, Turkey and others) who gathered at the Astana Think Tank Forum 2024, held in the Kazakh capital on 16 and 17 October.

A growing influence

In this changing order, and particularly as a new strategic axis takes shape in the East, middle powers have a unique potential: to form pragmatic coalitions, secure technological advances and encourage cultural and humanitarian exchanges. Yerkin Tukumov, director of the Kazakhstan Institute for Strategic Studies, which organised the forum, stresses that “these countries can develop lasting influence by investing in partnerships in research, health, education and science. Through this approach, middle powers become poles of stability in an increasingly fragmented world.”

It is a view shared by Michel Duclos of the Institut Montaigne during one of the forum’s round tables, in which he described in particular the assertive role played by countries such as Turkey, India and Saudi Arabia in the context of the war in Ukraine, calling them the “big winners” of the global geopolitical realignment and pointing to their increased ability to exert influence independently of the traditional superpowers. For the former diplomat, these middle powers are asserting themselves through their ability to balance their relationships and to take strategic initiatives.

Kazakhstan: a strategic and balanced position

As was seen recently at the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia, one of the major geopolitical poles is made up of nations (notably China, Russia and Iran) that surround Central Asia. In this context, “Kazakhstan, today more than ever, embodies the characteristics of a middle power”, confirmed Akan Rakhmetullin, First Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, in his opening address to the forum. He also stressed the importance of “Track Two diplomacy”, which enables analysts, researchers and policymakers to work together openly to find solutions to complex international challenges. “Despite global geopolitical turbulence, our foreign policy principles remain constant. We adhere to the key rules of multi-vector policy, balance, pragmatism and the protection of national interests,” he  stated.

According to the minister, the notion of a middle power rests on two main dimensions. The first is capacity, encompassing territorial and demographic size as well as political and economic weight. The second is a balanced position rooted in moderation. “It is precisely this strategic posture that allows Kazakhstan to wield a  degree of influence, by keeping away from extremes and acting as a mediator in regional conflicts,” he concluded.

A pivotal role in the face of global crises

At a time of mounting global crises – regional conflicts, economic turbulence, climate change, food and migration crises – middle powers could emerge as key players capable of stabilising international relations. President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev set out this vision in his opening address on the second day of the forum: “While the dominant powers clash and become bogged down in their rivalries, it falls to the middle powers to keep dialogue going and to support the structures that advance global cooperation.” For the Kazakh president and former Director-General of the United Nations Office at Geneva (UNOG), the ability of these nations to establish dialogue and preserve frameworks for cooperation is becoming paramount, particularly when the major powers find themselves paralysed by geopolitical rivalries, as is the case today between Russia or China and the Western powers.

The involvement of middle powers in resolving regional conflicts is all the more crucial as those conflicts grow more complex, not least with the emergence of non-state actors and proxy forces. The volatility of global supply chains, heightened by recent geopolitical tensions, and rising energy and food prices are exacerbating global challenges. In the face of such profound disruption, most participants at the forum stressed the importance of middle powers joining forces to promote stability and dialogue, taking an approach founded on cooperation rather than domination.

Building bridges, not walls

In a world where the major powers often turn to competition and confrontation, middle powers such as Kazakhstan have a valuable role to play in fostering cooperation. By forming alliances and coalitions geared towards pragmatic solutions, these countries can show that it is more worthwhile and beneficial to build bridges rather than walls. As the Kazakh President put it, “in the face of escalating international challenges, our collective future rests on our ability to work together and to put forward shared responses”.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.