Home / Conflicts / Normalisation of diplomatic relations between Libya and Israel: a non-starter?

Normalisation of diplomatic relations between Libya and Israel: a non-starter?

Libya’s Foreign Minister, Najla Mangoush, has been suspended from her post by the Prime Minister, Abdelhamid Dbeibah. The temporary dismissal follows her meeting with Israel’s Foreign Minister. The meeting, initiated by the United States, took place under the auspices of the Libyan Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani.

Following the disclosure, a wave of protests broke out in several cities across the country. Demonstrators chanted slogans in support of the Palestinian cause. Crowds also gathered outside the Presidency of the Council of Ministers and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 

Libya’s political class, in turn, condemned the meeting, describing it as “a dangerous move” and “a red line that must not be crossed”. The meeting reportedly failed to take into account “the feelings of the Libyan people”, thereby resulting in “the violation of Libyan law”. The Misurata municipal council and the council of notables condemned the meeting in a statement. The Union of Martyrs, meanwhile, considers “this act irresponsible”.

Faced with this widespread outcry, the Libyan government immediately suspended the minister by decree and placed her on “the list of persons not authorised to leave Libyan territory”.  Spirited out of the country by the internal security service, she has taken refuge in Istanbul. The government, weakened from within, denies this version of events and affirms that it “stands in solidarity with the Palestinian people”.

A commission of inquiry to examine the circumstances of the meeting has been set up by the Prime Minister. The minister will shortly appear before the commission of inquiry. The Prime Minister will make a hastily arranged visit to the Palestinian Embassy in Libya to affirm “his unwavering support for the Palestinian people”. 

  1. Behind the meeting 

Two senior officials in Dbeibah’s government have said that the Prime Minister was aware of the talks between the two foreign ministers. Brahim Dbeibah, the Prime Minister’s personal adviser and the instigator of the meeting, had prepared it in collaboration with Israeli figures. 

The Prime Minister had given him his approval to organise the meeting in Rome. On her return to Tripoli, the minister immediately informed the Prime Minister. 

Purpose of the meeting: 

The meeting forms part of US mediation efforts aimed at encouraging Libya to normalise its relations with Israel. The Abraham Accords, signed on 15 September 2020 in Washington, provide for the normalisation of diplomatic relations between Israel, on the one hand, and the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Sudan and Morocco, on the other. 

An initial meeting had been held between Prime Minister Dbeibah and CIA Director William Burns during the latter’s visit to Tripoli last January. Following that meeting, Prime Minister Dbeibah reportedly gave “his initial agreement to join the Abraham Accords”, but he “remained concerned about the popular reaction”. 

“A meeting that was above all cultural: preserving Libya’s Jewish heritage”

The Israeli Foreign Minister wished to explore possible cooperation with a view to building a relationship between the two countries. The aim, above all, is to preserve “the Libyan Jewish heritage”. An agreement would have made it possible to restore synagogues and Jewish cemeteries.  The Israeli minister said in a statement that the “meeting was the first step in establishing official relations”, adding that “Libya’s size and strategic location offer potential for both countries”. The talks reportedly also included “a discussion about history”. 

Beyond these matters, the establishment of “cooperation and assistance in humanitarian and agricultural affairs as well as water management” was discussed by the two foreign ministers.

Libya’s agricultural sector is currently underdeveloped. Access to Israeli agricultural technology would enable the country to develop. Water management remains Libya’s main problem, owing to the under-exploitation of the Great Man-Made River and the country’s desert climate.

A strategic meeting for Libya 

On the Libyan side, the meeting was a way of pre-empting the “political” moves made by Sadam Haftar (son of Field Marshal Haftar). With Field Marshal Haftar at risk of being sidelined in the forthcoming presidential elections, the Haftar clan is seeking to secure its “political” and economic survival. Sadam Haftar has travelled to Israel twice to request “diplomatic and military assistance” in exchange for normalisation with the Israeli state.

It should be noted that Israel, present in the east through its regional partners, has supplied weapons and technical assistance “to the military forces” of the east.

Having Israel as a “backer and ally” would allow Libyan politicians to secure the support of the United States. The current Libyan government has lost credibility and legitimacy in the eyes of Western countries because it has failed to respect the roadmap. Holding this meeting in Italy would probably have enabled the Prime Minister to gain the support of the European Union, and of the United States too. Above all, however, it would have served to delegitimise the Haftar clan. Recognition of the current Libyan government rendered all the acts undertaken by the Haftar clan de facto illegal and, above all, null and void.

Had the normalisation process with the State of Israel continued, the Israeli government could have negotiated only with Dbeibah’s government. 

Given the situation, no Libyan political figure will risk resuming talks with the State of Israel.

Foreign ministers: scapegoats for their governments?

The Foreign Minister: the revolutionary from Cyrenaica

Najla Mangoush, a lawyer by training, became a member of Libya’s National Transitional Council in 2011. Tasked with coordinating the cities opposed to Muammar Gaddafi’s regime, she would work mainly on resolving the Libyan conflict. 

Her last-minute appointment to the government, imposed by Aguila Salah, was badly received by the Libyan political class. The first Libyan woman to hold the post, the minister was criticised for her “pro-Western”, even “pro-American”, positions. She campaigns actively for the implementation of the United Nations roadmap, including the holding of free elections and the disarmament of the militias. 

Her lack of nationalism and her criticism of the Prime Minister during meetings hastened her downfall. This political manoeuvre by the Libyan Prime Minister enabled him to rid himself of a minister deemed “too active” and not “nationalist” enough. 

Targeted on several occasions by certain militias, she enjoyed enhanced protection from the internal security services. 

Israeli Foreign Minister: an architect of peace 

Eli Cohen was appointed Foreign Minister on 29 December 2022. Involved in normalisation efforts with Arab and African countries, he had organised the first official Israeli delegation to Khartoum.

Faced with public protest and opposition from part of the Israeli political class, the Israeli government has denounced “a diplomatic error” in making the meeting public. Having initially denied any knowledge of the meeting, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu issued a “directive requiring that all secret diplomatic meetings be approved by his office” on Tuesday.

Merav Michaeli, the Labour leader, said for her part that Cohen “should resign”. Described as “irresponsible and amateurish”, his conduct risks “deterring countries from embarking on a normalisation process with the Israeli state”. 

Moreover, according to Israeli government sources, the Israeli minister is said to have caused serious damage to Israeli diplomacy, and “burned a bridge that was still being built”. The media coverage of the meeting could have been avoided by imposing military censorship. 

A premature meeting…

This channel of communication set up by the United States undermines the credibility of the Netanyahu government, which was unable to keep its own administration in check. First, the Chatham House Rule, the guiding principle of back-channel diplomacy, was flouted. This diplomatic lapse has been sharply criticised by President Biden’s administration, which regards it as “amateurism”. The US administration “had hoped the meeting would remain discreet”.  

Second, the United States, which is returning to the Libyan economy, wishes to maintain good relations with Libyan stakeholders. Protecting US oil companies on Libyan soil is a priority. It is worth recalling that the NOC (National Oil Corporation) and US companies (Halliburton and Honeywell International) are negotiating a contract worth $1.4 billion. Halliburton could rebuild the Al Dhara oilfield in the Sirte Basin, while Honeywell would build a refinery in south-eastern Libya.

Trade has risen significantly. Exports of agricultural and food products, for example, amount to $41.55 million. The Libyan market represents an opportunity for American companies, particularly in the pharmaceutical and automotive sectors.

Beyond energy considerations, the Fezzan is a strategic location for the United States. The Fezzan is a gateway to the Sahel and a potential rear base to which the United States could fall back.

…but Ad impossibilia nemo tenetur

The Libyan public’s hostility towards this meeting may deter some Arab countries, already weakened from within, from starting, or even continuing, talks with Israel. 

The Arab Spring showed that changes of government could lead to bilateral agreements or treaties being repudiated.

For Arab countries, normalising relations with Israel is conditional on resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.  Although Muammar Gaddafi once proposed uniting the two countries by creating “Isratine”, negotiations appear to have stalled.

Dbeibah’s weakened government will no longer risk organising any meeting with Israel. It will therefore be necessary to wait for the next Libyan elections, in order to avoid a “second Arab Spring”.

Meanwhile, Israel could ask the Gulf states to act as intermediaries in the process of normalising relations with Libya… except that all these countries also have strategic interests in Libya…

Who will take that risk? 

Imen Chaanbi 

Director, France-Maghreb-Africa

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.