The Pearl of the Antilles. The world’s first free black republic. A place so enchanting that Haiti became the first destination of an international company offering dream holidays. What, then, has become of the daily life of the Haitian people, with a past so promising yet now seemingly so distant? The way the country is governed offers a fairly precise answer, at least for the “post-Duvalier” period1
Indeed, since the Duvalier era, Haitian politicians appear to have grown quite comfortable with a game of musical chairs. Those elected are quick to enjoy the privileges of office without serving out the normal length of their term2; this creates an obvious lack of the stability needed to set out clear policies and, above all, to follow through on their implementation. The lack of continuity among senior politicians makes it difficult to find credible interlocutors with a sense of mission for carrying out any project, whether humanitarian or in the field of economic development.
Moreover, several politicians are linked to the corruption that is rife in the country, and some have even been named as accomplices in the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse! Corruption appears to be a veritable cancer eating away at Haitian society. Canada has imposed sanctions on two former ministers and seized their assets held in Canada. At the same time, other political and business leaders were sanctioned because their actions enabled criminal groups to destabilise the country.3 Allegations of financial mismanagement have even been published concerning the Director General of the Haitian National Police, while police officers lack the resources to tackle the violence.
The country is currently going through an unprecedented period of violence whose main target is the Haitian population, which has fallen victim to senseless killings, kidnappings, rapes and all manner of atrocities. It is a thoroughly distressing spectacle of horror in a country that already holds the sad record for the most absolute poverty in the Americas! As if that were not enough, the country ranks unflatteringly in terms of perceived corruption4, a corruption that is undermining several layers of Haitian society, including the political class.
This violence remains, above all, a merciless gang war that meets little resistance from the authorities responsible for security and for protecting the population. Indeed, the question arises as to whether the Haitian National Police (HNP) can effectively counter these gangs and restore a climate of peace, particularly in the country’s capital. The HNP’s effectiveness is undermined by a lack of political will to tackle the scourge of corruption that is eating away at the institutions. Moreover, the judicial system is unable to fight corruption because numerous actors have, over the years, ensured impunity for those responsible for corruption and even for gang leaders. It is particularly troubling to note that the overall conviction rate in the judicial system is 3%, with a single conviction (in a corruption case) over the past 15 years5. Within the HNP itself, it is acknowledged that some police officers have collaborated, or are still collaborating, with certain gangs. Indeed, the leader of a major coalition of gangs is himself a former police officer6.
To the question: can the HNP defeat the gangs? The answer is no! Is outside help desirable and available? The answer is a faint yes, while few countries are volunteering for this role of supporting the HNP in neutralising the gangs.
So can a foreign military force intervene and help the HNP to quell this violence so that those responsible for these gangs can be brought to justice?
Haiti has been here before: in 2005, following the killing of a gang leader in Cité Soleil, the new gang leader sought to extend his influence and waged a campaign of violence similar to the one being seen today. The UN mission called for additional reinforcements and launched a military operation aimed at restoring security and thereby neutralising the new leadership of these gangs.
This military offensive, carried out in close cooperation with the HNP, succeeded in dismantling pockets of resistance held by certain gangs, in raising the level of security for the population and in helping police officers arrest gang members. Clearly, these results were visible only for as long as UN military forces were supporting the HNP. Given the state of the judicial system, and given that these gangs enjoy financial backing, material support and protection guaranteeing their impunity from various actors in Haitian society, it is highly likely that the gang phenomenon will re-emerge once the military operation is over.
Se rat kay k ap manje kay7 . Greater security for the entire Haitian population cannot be guaranteed without strengthening the country’s institutions and, above all, without closer oversight by the international community of its democratic machinery. The word “trusteeship” has been uttered on several occasions, and it would no doubt be regrettable to come to that, but is there any other solution?
1: François Duvalier, nicknamed Papa Doc, ruled the country from 1958 to 1971, and his son Jean-Claude Duvalier, nicknamed Baby Doc, took over from 1971 to 1986
2: For example, it is striking that since 1988 few politicians have held the post of prime minister for more than a year; some have even held it for barely a few months!
3: Details of the sanctions can be found at https://www.canada.ca/fr/affaires mondiales/nouvelles/2022/11/le-canada-impose-des-sanctions-supplementaires-a-des membres-de-lelite-politique-haitienne.html
4: According to Transparency International, Haiti ranked 171st out of 180 countries in 2022. The slide continues: the country ranked 89th in 2002.
5: https://www.undp.org/fr/haiti/actualites/appuyer-la-justice-et-combattre-limpunite-en-haiti
6: This is Jimmy Chérisy, alias Barbecue, a former police officer who dreams of becoming… president of Haiti
7: Translation: It is the house rat that eats the house
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






