“We must arm ourselves with realism; reason must prevail over passion” – President Habib Bourguiba
- Tunisia: a migration gateway to the European Union?
The Tunisian President’s recent speech caused consternation in the international community, which accused him of discrimination against African migrants. Beyond its content, it is important to examine the reasons that led to this situation in a country beset by a multidimensional crisis and a breakdown in the bond between citizens and the political class.
Indeed, the migration question is first and foremost a matter of security policy. The authorities’ primary aim is to enforce the legislative and regulatory provisions1. But it is also a matter of complying with the Barcelona Declaration2, the founding act of a comprehensive partnership between the European Union and the 12 countries of the southern Mediterranean. Tunisia, like its Maghreb neighbours, must work actively with the European Union in combating irregular migration. This partnership on migration3 was seen as an opportunity to strengthen their cooperation in tackling uncontrolled population movements, namely halting the flow of clandestine migrants, strengthening the legal arsenal (penalising both the organisers of and the participants in clandestine departures), training coastal surveillance personnel and providing detection equipment.
For most migrants, Tunisia is a transit point on the way to Europe. The European Union blames Tunisia for the influx of African migrants who have chosen Europe as their final destination. Tunisia has been forced to take on the role of “border guard”, and has done so to satisfy the demands of the European Union. This rhetoric stems from pressure exerted by the European Union, which makes its financial aid to Tunisia conditional.
Moreover, Tunisia, which has become the platform for this irregular migration (both a waiting zone and a transit zone), can no longer cope economically and financially with this massive influx. Successive economic crises and social tensions have poisoned an increasingly toxic situation in the country. Social media has erupted with denunciations of a supposed “great cultural and religious replacement“4, with calls for a firm and radical response from the Tunisian government. Some migrants are accused and persecuted by a small minority. They become easy targets and are blamed for the ills said to be poisoning Tunisian society (drug trafficking, sects, theft and so on).
Some denounce millions of undocumented migrants5, yet no distinction is made between people with legal status and those without it. This conflation affects some Tunisian citizens, as well as some migrants with legal status, including students.
The economic6 and social crisis affecting Tunisia triggered a nationalist and populist protest movement7. Defending religion and “Arab” culture is equated with defending national interests. In a country beset by a social and ideological divide, it was necessary to rally the people around a nationalist ideology in order to assert its independence and sovereignty. This drive for unity is also a means for Tunisia to avert social unrest (rising prices, etc.).
It is worth recalling that on 29 December 1983 Tunisia experienced its largest popular revolt (the bread riots)8 since independence. On the brink of civil war, President Habib Bourguiba declared a curfew and imposed a state of emergency9. The 1983 riot remains etched in the minds of all Tunisians.
Beyond these socio-economic aspects, Tunisia is caught in a pincer movement by its neighbours. Algeria is driving its migrants out into the Algerian desert, with no intention of either integrating them or returning them to their countries of origin. Libya, gripped by its own internal conflict, has to manage its own migration crisis and does not hesitate to open its borders. Most migrants cross the Fezzan to reach Tunisia. Since 2011, Tunisia has been a host country for Libyan refugees10 and Syrian refugees alike. Moreover, the Sudanese crisis threatens to worsen the situation, given that Libya is unable to cope with a humanitarian crisis in the south of the country.
Pressure from the international community and NGOs has contributed to this political imbroglio.
Indeed, on the European side, Italy was the first country to denounce this situation. In addition to undocumented migrants from Central, West and sub-Saharan Africa, a new form of irregular immigration has been observed. Before the 2011 revolution, irregular migrants were mainly young Tunisians hoping to try their luck in Europe. After the revolution, however, a new form of irregular immigration emerged, made up of Tunisians of all ages and all social backgrounds, including entire families. Whole neighbourhoods are mobilising to help Tunisian citizens leave the country for the European Eldorado that would offer them a better quality of life.11 Some Tunisians never reach their destination because they are intercepted by the Tunisian authorities12. Others drown and wash up on Tunisian beaches (Zarzis). Italy remains the destination of choice13 but also a springboard to France and Belgium.
This speech, admittedly clumsy in its wording, was welcomed by part of the Tunisian population but, above all, came at just the right moment for Italy, which had at last found its Mediterranean ally in its fight against illegal immigration.
Faced with a protest movement, the Tunisian President issued several reforms14 in favour of migrants, but these remain insufficient in the eyes of some human rights organisations. Moreover, these measures have not quelled the anger of some African countries, which have denounced trade agreements with Tunisia, expelled Tunisians and boycotted Tunisian products15.
This migration situation is fuelled by the economic and social difficulties of the countries of origin. The stigmatisation of Tunisia should not obscure the fact that this tolerant and open country was at the very heart of the creation of “African Unity”.
- Tunisia: a symbol of pan-Africanism
Tunisia lies at the heart of Africa, both in its geographical position and in its involvement in the pan-African movement.
Indeed, the country played a vital role in the creation of the Organisation of African Unity in 1963 in Addis Ababa. The great independence leaders of the time had but one goal: “a rich, proud and independent Africa”.
President Habib Bourguiba’s rapprochement with Presidents Félix Houphouët Boigny, Léopold Sédar Senghor and Hamani Diori helped to increase its influence in French-speaking Africa. It was in this way that the Agency for Cultural and Technical Cooperation (the forerunner of the OIF) was created in 1970. The country hosts the African Development Bank and is a member of several international bodies of the African Union16.
The arrival of President Ben Ali in 1987 changed the picture and put an end to all forms of pan-African activism. National policy17 focused on developing relations with Europe, thereby setting aside South-South relations. Nevertheless, the government maintained economic and social ties with its neighbouring countries (Algeria, Tunisia, Libya and Morocco).
Tunisian Presidents Moncef Marzouki and Béji Caïd Essebsi, for their part, preferred to build economic and financial ties with “brother” African countries through a proactive policy. In 2022, the Minister of the Economy and Planning, Samir Saïed18, sought to strengthen Tunisia’s economic diplomacy, with the aim of supporting companies wishing to export to Africa while attracting foreign investors to Tunisia.
Promoting Tunisian expertise and know-how in various fields should enable the country to establish itself in several African countries19 that are members of COMESA20. The growing number of business delegations, notably through the Tunisia African Business Council (TABC), will foster the internationalisation of Tunisian companies in Africa. The TABC thus aims “to be a leading player for better South-South cooperation promoting sustainable development and shared prosperity for the peoples of Africa”21. Tunisia thus contributes to and takes part economically in various development projects benefiting African countries. But the country is also a host nation for African students, thanks to the free movement of people22.
Solutions to migration problems must be considered as a whole, involving the countries of origin. A better understanding between peoples and closer political ties will make it possible to tackle migration issues while fostering economic exchanges.
It is therefore timely to embark on in-depth work based on South-South cooperation, which is not at odds with North-South cooperation.
- Tunisia: a unique and privileged partner for the European Union
Under the impetus of the Italian Prime Minister, Giorgia Meloni, the European Union has chosen to maintain a “strong relationship and invest in stability and prosperity”23. The European Union is thus offering more than one billion euros over the long term, with the aim of strengthening its partnership with Tunisia in its fight against illegal immigration while supporting the Tunisian economy24.
The economic agreements, the grants awarded and all the measures also encouraged by Italy should make it possible to resolve this situation. Removing pressure points, regulating immigration and fostering the economic development of both countries are integral parts of political and economic diplomacy.
The Tunisian economy is attractive to foreign investors25, both because of the growing diversification of its economy26 and because of its mineral and energy resources.
Beyond these economic aspects, Tunisia remains a bridge between Africa and the European Union. Its geographical position and its cultural proximity to the West make the country a loyal partner that has been able to weather every crisis without abandoning its humanist values.
The ties that bind the European Union and Tunisia are unbreakable, including with France. President Habib Bourguiba, father and founder of the Tunisian nation, the only secular country in the Maghreb, waged his “fight for freedom by invoking the message of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity.”27
Impartial in conflicts, Tunisia has always pursued a policy of positive neutrality, which has enabled it to maintain fraternal ties, particularly with its neighbouring countries. It is also a land of refuge for public figures and for migrants fleeing inter-ethnic conflicts, civil wars and humanitarian crises.
Its foreign policy is a blend of pan-Arabism and pan-Africanism, to which are added the precepts of European diplomacy. Establishing collaborative initiatives should enable states to implement a common policy while affirming the unity of their peoples.
Tunisia, a true legatus, is a deus ex machina for European countries, particularly France, which are seeking political legitimacy, or even a strategic diplomacy, in Africa.
By strengthening its strategic partnership with Tunisia, the European Union has at last found its preferred interlocutor in Africa.
- Law 2004-6 of 3 February 2004 “organising the punishment of irregular entry into and exit from the territory” : the influx of migrants into Tunisian territory, which obliges landlords, on pain of penalty, to request a residence permit and to report to the police station any foreigners they are housing. Landlords found in breach have been forced to evict people with irregular status. The Tunisian government has chartered flights to several African countries.
- Barcelona Euro-Mediterranean Dialogue, 27 and 28 November 1995, establishing the Euro-Mediterranean conferences between the EU and the 12 countries of the Mediterranean basin
- The 5+5 Dialogue serves as a sub-regional forum for the ten Western Mediterranean countries that have taken part in it since its creation: five lie to the north of the Mediterranean Sea (Spain, France, Italy, Malta and Portugal) and five are located to the south of it (Algeria, Libya, Morocco, Mauritania and Tunisia).
- “Changing the demographic make-up of the country”
“Uncontrolled masses, a horde of illegal migrants whose aim is to turn Tunisia into a purely African country and to wrench it away from the Arab Muslim nations” – speech by the Tunisian President.
- There are reportedly more than 20,000 irregular migrants (Ministry of the Interior figures)
- Tunisia’s debt stands at 80% of its GDP. The country can no longer borrow abroad, which is leading to recurrent shortages of certain staple goods, such as flour, sugar and rice, which are purchased and imported by the state. The current government is trying to negotiate a new loan with the IMF.
The country is in difficult talks with the IMF over a new loan of nearly two billion dollars.
- It was becoming urgent to respond to the expectations of a minority.
- President Habib Bourguiba had to intervene to cancel the proposal by Mohamed Mzali’s government to cut subsidies on cereal prices. This reform followed the austerity plan demanded by the IMF.
- For the third time in 27 years of independence, the state called in the army to quell popular anger.
- Since the Libyan revolution (2011), Tunisia has taken in more than 1 million Libyan refugees.
- According to official figures from the Interior Ministry, between 2015 and 2020 some 39,500 engineers and 3,500 doctors left the country – and their numbers are rising year on year: entire families, unaccompanied minors (1,046 in 2020, 2,042 in 2021 and 2,424 minors in eight and a half months of 2022), and women who are graduates, pregnant or travelling with their young children (206 women in 2020 and 526 in 8.5 months of 2022).
- More than 23,000 irregular migrants for “crossing maritime borders irregularly”.
- More than 16,000 irregular Tunisian migrants had been intercepted off the Italian coast (2022)
- The President called for “measures to be taken to improve the situation of foreigners in Tunisia and to simplify the procedures for regularising their status: extending residence certificates from three to six months, and facilitating voluntary return operations within an organised framework with their diplomatic missions.
- Senegal, Guinea, Côte d’Ivoire and Mali. A blacklist of boycotted products was published on social media.
- Tunisia is an observer member of ECOWAS, the Economic Community of West African States.
- The President has attended the African Union summit only once.
- Information and discussion day on the internationalisation of Tunisian companies into African markets, 17 August 2022, Tunis.
- Five promising sectors in 15 African countries (11 of them sub-Saharan) with strong potential for Tunisian companies: agri-food, health and the pharmaceutical industry, construction and public works, information and communication technologies (ICT), and education and higher education.
- The Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA).
- https://tabc.org.tn/service/nos-services/.
- Free movement under Libya’s policy of closer ties with African states (CEN-SAD)
- Speech by Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, on 11 June 2023 during her meeting with Tunisian President Kaïs Saïed.
- This involves stepping up investment in Tunisia, notably in support of the digital sector, investment in Tunisia’s exports of renewable energy and the extension of the EU’s Erasmus student exchange programme to Tunisia.
- The stock of FDI reached USD 33.4 billion, or nearly 72% of the country’s GDP. According to the latest figures from the Tunisian Investment Authority, FDI inflows into the country rose by 18.4% year on year in 2022 to reach 2.214 billion TND. More than 3,300 foreign companies were registered on Tunisian soil
- Agriculture, manufacturing, industry and the tertiary sector (tourism, finance, services, etc.)
- Speech by Habib Bourguiba following the end of the protectorate (Tunisian independence)
Translated from French. The French original prevails.






