Home / Analysis / Swiss neutrality and military AI: a label to counter algorithmic warfare

Swiss neutrality and military AI: a label to counter algorithmic warfare

As autonomous weapons systems make their way onto the battlefield and international negotiations stall, the specialist Axel Mazolo is proposing a Swiss counter-model: a certification label for military algorithms. It is an initiative that is at once technical and diplomatic, and true to the DNA of Swiss neutrality.

In an ambitious report, Axel Mazolo puts forward an idea that is as pragmatic as it is bold: the creation of a Swiss label to certify the algorithms built into lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS). Faced with the paralysis of United Nations institutions and the accelerating militarisation of algorithms, such a label would not be an ethical gimmick but a powerful diplomatic lever.

LAWS — weapons capable of identifying and striking a target without human validation — are already in use in conflicts such as those in Ukraine and Libya. The speed at which they act, combined with the opacity of their algorithms, calls into question the very foundations of international humanitarian law: the distinction between civilians and combatants, proportionality, and accountability in the event of error.

Axel Mazolo stresses that the law is struggling to keep pace with technological innovation, and that multilateral diplomacy, trapped by consensus, is today incapable of putting safeguards in place. In this vacuum, he proposes anchoring Swiss action in a “digital neutrality” suited to our times.

Digital neutrality, according to Mazolo, goes beyond military abstention. It becomes active, driven by concrete commitments: rejecting algorithmic proliferation, promoting cybersecurity and guaranteeing the transparency of intelligent weapons systems.

This is where the Swiss label comes in. Issued by an independent foundation under Swiss law, it would draw on standards from the aviation, medical and financial sectors. The certification process would assess not only a system’s technical robustness, but also its compliance with humanitarian law, its resilience to cyberattacks and the ethical governance of its development.

“We are not certifying perfection,” Axel Mazolo explains, “but a rigorous, transparent and auditable process. A standard of due diligence that holds developers and operators accountable.”

The idea, though praised for its coherence, is not without pitfalls. The major powers — the United States, China, Russia — have little interest in having their weapons examined by a third party, however neutral. The risk of “label-washing”, exploiting certification for image purposes, is real. Likewise, some activists fear that this technical approach will divert attention from a more radical goal: an outright ban on LAWS.

But Axel Mazolo stands by this middle way. In his view, a label does not replace an international treaty but prepares the ground. It creates islands of trust, encourages ethics to be built in “by design”, and gives structure to a debate too often diluted in abstraction or technological one-upmanship.

Mazolo’s project follows in the tradition of Swiss good offices, but with 21st-century tools. It is addressed as much to diplomats as to engineers, to lawyers as to cybersecurity experts. In a fragmented world, where innovation runs ahead of regulation, it invites Switzerland to turn its historic neutrality into normative power.

In the final analysis, it is a call not to let war become an exclusively algorithmic affair. And to affirm, through standards where treaties are lacking, that humans must never be taken out of the loop.

“Neutrality is no longer silence. It is the active building of peace. Even in cyberspace.” — Axel Mazolo

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.