Home / Opinion / Why Trump’s security strategy on the EU will not hold

Why Trump’s security strategy on the EU will not hold

The document setting out the national security strategy of the United States, published by the Trump administration, has unsettled a good many European countries. Some, which for decades relied on America for their security, find themselves orphaned. Others, such as France and Britain, which have built up strategic autonomy, albeit imperfect, fear above all a reversal of alliances that would leave Ukraine at risk of being abandoned in its armed confrontation with Russia.

Yet this document, as ideological as it is strategic, reveals little that is really new from the current occupants of the White House. JD Vance in Munich, President Donald Trump and his mouthpieces have already stated and restated their “Huntingtonian” (clash of civilisations) vision of the world order, and have encouraged so-called “patriotic” and anti-European parties to dismantle the European Union.

This document, which seeks to assert total US domination over the world, cannot be content with a European Union that stands in the way of that domination, not least by seeking to regulate social media, the main vehicle of the MAGA culture war. The €120 million fine imposed on X, Elon Musk’s platform, and his response calling for the European Union to be “dismantled”, are the latest and most telling example. Trump’s America clearly prefers vassalised countries on the Old Continent to a Union which, though imperfect, is able, through its unity, to say no to it in the name of its values and its interests.

The document’s reach should also be put into perspective. It is, after all, merely the ideological expression of a government that still depends on the workings of democracy. The midterms loom in a year’s time, in November 2026, and the American media are beginning to talk of a “lame duck ” in reference to President Trump. Several signs indeed suggest that the blind obedience of Republican lawmakers, and even of some voices in the MAGA world, is no longer unanimous. Trump is now less feared than certain electoral signals ahead of the November 2026 vote, or than certain issues that are embarrassing this presidency.

First, the results of the Tennessee congressional by-election rang out like a warning shot in the Republican camp. In this state, an impregnable GOP stronghold, their candidate won by only 8%, whereas the winning margin in previous elections had been around 20 points. “We are literally three people away from losing the majority” in the House of Representatives, the candidate Tim Burchett had said before his election.

After the defeats suffered by the party of the elephant in Virginia and New Jersey, Republican lawmakers are beginning to worry about the shadow Trump is casting over their re-election. And while it was likely that the Democratic candidate would win the New York mayoralty, the fact that the winner was Zohran Mamdani, an openly socialist Muslim, has also caused unease within MAGA. Why? Because President Trump had threatened to cut off federal funding to America’s largest city if Mamdani were elected, and instead he showed himself all smiles alongside the newly elected mayor in front of the cameras. For the MAGA camp, it is a betrayal. For Republicans, it is a further sign that Trump’s threats are fizzling out.

/

In another sign of Trump’s lame-duck status, the president had to bow to pressure from Republican lawmakers over the release of documents from the case file of the child sex offender Epstein. The resignation of Marjorie Taylor Greene, one of Trump’s most loyal supporters, amid a torrent of insults from the president on his Truth Social network, in the name of truth and of defending the young women who fell victim to this child sex abuse ring close to political and financial power, is another symptom of the malaise.

It is a malaise that also shows up in the opinion polls. According to a Reuters/Ipsos poll, President Donald Trump’s approval rating has fallen to its lowest level since his return to the White House, as voters grow increasingly frustrated with persistent inflation and the cost of living. It has even dropped 6 points among his Republican base, from 88% to 82%. Meanwhile, speculation about his declining health and stamina is becoming ever more widespread.

While it is true that Europe has lost ground economically and commercially, it is not, finally, by giving up its capacity for joint action that it will manage to hold on to a place in the whirlwind market of artificial intelligence and, more broadly, of new technologies. But when MAGA ideologues seek to weaken Europe, the American business world says: “Be careful”.

The head of America’s largest bank, Jamie Dimon, chief executive of J.P. Morgan, put it in his own words at a conference addressing defence industry executives. “A weak Europe is bad for us, for the entire free and democratic world.” Blowing up the EU? “That is exactly what our adversaries want. Every man for himself – that is all China is asking for. Europe is a major ally in every respect, including on shared values,” he said.

It is far from certain that the national security strategy concerning Europe will last only as long as Trumpism, which is already no longer quite so triumphant.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Tagged:
La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.