Home / Opinion / Can Trump go beyond the release of the hostages?

Can Trump go beyond the release of the hostages?

By Sébastien Boussois *

A few days before his inauguration at the White House on 20 January, Donald Trump was fuming about Benjamin Netanyahu to his close advisers, telling one of them furiously: “There is no way that (…) Netanyahu is going to ruin my ceremony!” After months and months of deadlock under the Democrats, there were indeed only a few short days left to secure the release of the first Israeli hostages in 13 months (once again under Qatar’s auspices) and to chalk up a first diplomatic success for the new Republican administration. And to show that he was the “best”!

Having promised to settle the wars in Ukraine and Gaza in short order, Trump and his transition team had already taken the initiative from last November, conducting joint negotiations with Biden’s advisers to secure a ceasefire and the release of the Israeli hostages in Gaza before he took office. It was no easy task, and Trump knew it. The dream of clinching two ceasefires before taking office soon faded. With the effort between Russia and Ukraine proving more complex than expected – President Putin’s fault, according to Trump – he decided to stake everything on the Israeli-Palestinian file. He needed at the very least to wrest an agreement, so as to have something strong and tangible to present to international opinion on the big day and to show that the political “bulldozer” was back and that it was not all speeches and poetry. He had to make a decisive break with the Democrats’ feebleness. 

The art of the “deal” is his obsession. And he practises it with his enemies and his friends alike. Once again, while many experts and specialists in Europe were telling us that the 47th President of the United States was thick as thieves with the master of the Kremlin and the Israeli Prime Minister, it turned out that Donald Trump did not, after all, wield all-powerful, all-knowing sway over the two men. Above all, it became apparent, like a truth revealed to the world, that he would not let his so-called “friends” get away with everything either. With Putin resisting the creation of an international buffer force led by the Europeans on Ukrainian soil to keep the “peace” in the event of an agreement signed between Russia and Ukraine, it was Netanyahu’s turn to drag things out, as Hamas had done for weeks, before a deal was struck as quickly as possible ahead of Inauguration Day. Unease was spreading through the ranks of Trump’s inner circle.

Netanyahu knew he had a great deal to lose by making compromises, starting with power. He had paid the price in 1996. But Trump’s special envoy, Steven Wittcoff, a real estate investor by trade catapulted into the role of the President’s special envoy to the Middle East and steered remotely by his master, ultimately pulled off the gamble that Biden never managed. Despite 15 months of talks, proposals and trips to the Middle East by Anthony Blinken, the former President was certainly lacking something that Trump has in spades: nerve. What Israelis call chutzpah, audacity. The billionaire applied what he does best: maximum pressure to finally bring Benjamin Netanyahu to heel. The Prime Minister could not risk falling under an outgoing US Democrat, but he could hope to obtain strong guarantees from the incoming Republican president that the former administration was no longer able to offer him. 

In the end, the first three hostages left Gaza on 19 January, the day before the inauguration. The event was covered by the international media, which remained cautious, since this was obviously not a peace agreement. But they were also cautious about whom to credit with this major diplomatic success. While Joe Biden, in his final days in office, proudly announced the release and claimed a large share of the credit, Trump was pulling the blanket over to his side, announcing on his social network that all the credit belonged to his advisers, and in particular to Steven Witkoff. Now, nothing is won, and from here on the entire success of the current truce, or its failure, rests on Trump’s shoulders alone. Yet the truce is fragile and stretched out over a long period – time being enemy number one in the Middle East. Everything could fall apart again over the releases scheduled over several weeks. Then will come the crucial moment when decisions will have to be taken that satisfy everyone on issues fraught with consequences: the return of displaced people, the withdrawal of the Israeli army, the fate of a Hamas that is far from decimated, the future administration of Gaza, a Palestinian state. On this last point, the US President has been clear from the outset: nothing during his term. But in the Middle East, nothing has been definitive for decades, neither peace nor war. In the meantime, the best Trump can achieve is to return to the political recipe that works least badly on the ground: the status quo. Giving assurances to Israel, containing the Palestinians, and allowing a return to everyday routine without upending the situation. That would be the lesser evil after more than a year of deadly war on both sides. Nothing more. 

*PhD in political science, researcher on the Arab world and geopolitics, lecturer in international relations at IHECS (Brussels), associate of the  CNAM Paris (Security and Defence Team), the Institut d’Etudes de Géopolitique Appliquée (IEGA Paris), the Nordic Center For Conflict Transformation (NCCT Stockholm) and the Observatoire Géostratégique de Genève (Switzerland).

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.