Since its founding in 1954, the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) has made Europe a leader in fundamental research. Its decision to end all collaboration with Russia raises questions at a time when China is honing extremely powerful tools. Can Europe’s scientific community keep its lead? Interview with Arnaud Marsollier, CERN spokesperson.
CERN was built to promote peace through dialogue between researchers. The discovery of the Higgs boson in 2012, which shed light on the origin of matter in the universe and earned the researchers Peter Higgs (Scottish, who died last April) and François Englert (Belgian) the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2013, confirms the expertise and competitiveness of CERN’s infrastructure. That infrastructure now faces a challenge from China, which plans to build a 100 km particle accelerator, four times more powerful than CERN’s. Moreover, CERN, which was built to promote peace through dialogue between researchers, has decided to strip Russia of its observer status, confirming that spaces of neutrality are increasingly rare. Without its collaboration with Russia, will the European project be strong enough to keep its lead in scientific research, not least over China? Arnaud Marsollier, CERN spokesperson, answers.
La Tribune des Nations (LTDN): How does CERN work?
Arnaud Marsollier (AM): CERN is the world’s largest laboratory for fundamental physics, and its role is to build infrastructure, particle accelerators in particular, for the benefit of the physics community, enabling physicists to explore the infinitely small and to investigate how nature works at the most fundamental level. Today CERN is best known for the LHC, the Large Hadron Collider, a unique facility where the Higgs boson was discovered in 2012. CERN works for what we call “users”, who come from all over the world (more than 100 nationalities). There are 23 Member States, and there are collaborations with countries on every continent. Binding long-term decisions are taken by the CERN Council, made up of representatives of each Member State. They attend every Council meeting, and each pair of delegates consists of one person from the scientific world and another from the political world.
LTDN: What have been the scientific consequences of the discovery of the Higgs boson in 2012?
AM: The Higgs boson is not just any particle. Its discovery completes the theory of the Standard Model, which describes all the elementary particles. Through the Higgs field, this particle gives other particles their mass. It is therefore a key to deepening our understanding. However, there are many mysteries, not least dark matter. When we observe the universe, we see only a tiny part of it. We know that dark matter exists because we are able to see some of its manifestations, particularly gravitational ones. For example, galaxies do not rotate at the speed at which they should according to the current model of physics. Some theorists are proposing new lines of thinking that go beyond the Standard Model to explain dark matter, for example the theory of supersymmetry. We have not yet explored everything, and we may have reached certain limits, so a new accelerator could enable us to go further.
LTDN: Beyond dark matter, what are the other major subjects CERN is working on?
AM: The Higgs boson is not just any particle. Its discovery completes the theory of the Standard Model, which describes all the elementary particles. Through the Higgs field, this particle gives other particles their mass. It is therefore a key to deepening our understanding. However, there are many mysteries, not least dark matter. When we observe the universe, we see only a tiny part of it. We know that dark matter exists because we are able to see some of its manifestations, particularly gravitational ones. For example, galaxies do not rotate at the speed at which they should according to the current model of physics. Some theorists are proposing new lines of thinking that go beyond the Standard Model to explain dark matter, for example the theory of supersymmetry. We have not yet explored everything, and we may have reached certain limits, so a new accelerator could enable us to go further.
Then there are all the questions surrounding gravity that go hand in hand with thinking about dark matter. We also want to refine our understanding of the interactions between particles and the Higgs boson. We had imagined that this particle could exist, but its discovery opens the door to new research. It is now 12 years since we discovered it. But in reality we have merely glimpsed it, as in a slightly blurred photograph, and we must keep studying it to bring that photograph into focus. Within 3 years, we will start up the High-Luminosity LHC, which will increase the number of collisions by a factor of 7 to 10, raising the probability of seeing new things.
LTDN: How does CERN’s work fit into contemporary challenges (the climate crisis, for example)? Can its discoveries be applied directly to civilian life?
AM: We are the only ones to build certain complex infrastructure, because we do a type of research that is unique in the world and that forces us to be creative. These technologies can be used elsewhere. Our technology transfer team works with civil society and with industry. Magnets, vacuum technologies, certain lasers, anything involving radiation, and computing are examples of these “transferable” technologies. The WEB was invented at CERN for research purposes, to share research and data – something everyone now does with their mobile phone.
On the climate, one of the important areas of research and development is magnet superconductivity. To run our accelerator today we use cryogenics: the machine operates at almost absolute zero, and that requires a great deal of energy. Very strong currents have to be injected into the animals, and this temperature enables superconductivity (the absence of resistance in the magnets). This makes it possible to use thinner cables without any loss of energy. To build a larger accelerator that is more efficient in terms of energy consumption, the technological breakthrough we dream of would be superconducting magnets at a higher temperature. There are probably other groups around the world also working on this. Indeed, the start-up industry often comes up with breakthrough technologies because it invests heavily in research. But superconducting magnets involve highly specialised research, and we are probably the only ones capable of doing it. If we manage to develop them, it will be revolutionary for society. It will not solve the climate problem in its entirety, but there is no denying that demand for energy is rising even though we are trying to limit our consumption.
LTDN: What more would the FCC bring compared with the upgraded version of the LHC?
AM: If we still cannot understand dark matter with the upgraded LHC, the FCC (Future Circular Collider) could enable us to do so. When we look at the universe, we know that we understand only 5% of it. So there is something fundamental that we have not grasped. What we do in fundamental research brings together people from all over the world, because this research benefits humanity. We are human; we need to understand and to advance knowledge. Perhaps the 95% of the universe that we manage to understand will be revolutionary and will change our view of the world. The sheer scale of the FCC project makes several things possible. It would allow us to carry out experiments of the same kind as those we did before. Before the hadron collider, we had LEP, in the same tunnel, which accelerated electrons. The protons we accelerate today are 2,000 times heavier than electrons. The FCC would be 91 km long and, initially, it would accelerate electrons and positrons. Unlike protons, electrons are elementary particles. The products of collisions between small particles are “cleaner” than those of collisions between heavy particles.
So if there is something to be seen, it will be easier to detect. Proton collisions in the LHC generate a great deal of “noise”, so the data coming out of the detectors has to be sifted. Even though computing helps us, it would be simpler to process data with less noise. The advantage of proton collisions is that we can reach very high energies, which allows us to discover heavier particles. The two essential aspects of a possible next machine are precision, which allows us to refine our understanding of particles and to discover new phenomena, and energy, which gives access to a world of particles that is not yet within our reach. The only high-energy particles we can find outside our laboratories are cosmic particles originating from black holes or the sun, for example, but they are difficult to study because they are far less numerous than those we create in accelerators. With the technologies available to us, the only way we know to achieve both precision and energy is to build bigger accelerators. We are working on concepts for the future, with more efficient acceleration techniques (the AWAKE experiment, which works with plasma), but these are still at an embryonic stage. Of course, we are reaching the limits of the circular accelerator concept, and other things will have to be invented, unless we manage to develop a breakthrough technology for magnets.
LTDN: China, too, plans to build a 100 km particle accelerator (CEPC). Could this project challenge the leading position of CERN, and therefore of Europe, in the field of fundamental physics?
AM: The Higgs boson is not just any particle. Its discovery completes the theory of the Standard Model, which describes all the elementary particles. Through the Higgs field, this particle gives other particles their mass. It is therefore a key to deepening our understanding. However, there are many mysteries, not least dark matter. When we observe the universe, we see only a tiny part of it. We know that dark matter exists because we are able to see some of its manifestations, particularly gravitational ones. For example, galaxies do not rotate at the speed at which they should according to the current model of physics. Some theorists are proposing new lines of thinking that go beyond the Standard Model to explain dark matter, for example the theory of supersymmetry. We have not yet explored everything, and we may have reached certain limits, so a new accelerator could enable us to go further.
It is still too early to say, as both projects are at an early stage of development. What this project tells us today is that there is genuine interest in building this kind of machine. The global physics community has met many times, whether in Europe, the United States or Asia, to understand the implications of the discovery of the Higgs boson. It is becoming a tool for further exploration, and we do not yet understand it very well. The top priority for the whole world, whatever the continent, is to build a Higgs boson “factory”. If several continents decide to take part in this venture, leadership could shift, and that is not what we want. We believe CERN has considerable experience, expertise and infrastructure. Before particles enter the LHC, they have already been accelerated by the upstream accelerator chain. In the 1980s, in the United States, there was a major project for an accelerator of 80 km, I believe. They had started building it, and it had cost several billion dollars. After a few years, they abandoned the whole thing. One of the explanations, beyond the technological challenges, is that building such an infrastructure from scratch in the middle of nowhere is neither the most sensible nor the most sustainable solution. In Europe, we have been investing in infrastructure for 70 years, in machines and in workshops. There are also all the power lines that already run there, so there is no need for fresh investment. CERN’s success lies precisely in the gradual increase in the size of its accelerators. There is surely a limit to this expansion, and the FCC will no doubt be the final step, but history has shown us that by building on what we have done, we have managed to discover new things.
LTDN: During his visit to China, the President of the Council highlighted the similarities between CERN’s FCC project and China’s CEPC. Did China draw on European know-how?
AM: There can be no industrial espionage, because of the way CERN is constituted. You have to go back to its history. CERN was built in the aftermath of the Second World War, with the aim of bringing Europeans together to create a major nuclear physics laboratory. There was a great boom in fundamental physics at the start of the 20th century, and then came two world wars that paralysed everything in Europe. Forces had to be pooled around these questions of fundamental physics. By its constitution, CERN was conceived as a laboratory of peace, where everything that is done and discussed is accessible to everyone. So we cannot talk about industrial espionage; the plans for the FCC as we envisage it can be found on conference websites and on CERN’s website – nothing is secret. If visitors come, they can take photos everywhere. By its very nature, particle physics has always been highly global. There are 110 nationalities at CERN, and there have always been very strong collaborations with the Americans and the Japanese, but also with the Chinese.
Collaboration has always gone hand in hand with competition. When the LHC was being built, the Americans were still hoping to discover the Higgs boson before us, and this was the subject of articles that fuelled the suspense of the race.
LTDN: In 2022, the CERN Council decided to end its collaboration with Russia and Belarus. Some scientists have criticised the decision, seeing scientific research as a way of building ties between states beyond political conflicts. How do you explain this political ban?
AM: The idea of sharing science and moving beyond conflicts is indeed central to the conception of CERN. Science is a unifying force. It is true that a great deal has been said about how, during the Cold War, CERN was a place where researchers could still exchange ideas and meet. That does not mean it was easy. But we cannot ignore the turmoil in the world. CERN is certainly an island of peace and a unique place where many different nationalities mix, including enemies working together on scientific projects, but we are not cut off from the world.
When there is turmoil in the world, we are affected. Let us hope the future will be better. For now, this is a decision taken by the member states. The sanctions imposed independently of CERN – bans on transporting equipment and on researchers travelling – would in any case have complicated joint work. CERN has taken a clear decision to distance itself from Russia. I do not think the loss of Russian expertise will affect CERN’s work, since we have 110 nationalities working on our experiments. We cannot ignore the fact that the collaboration with Russia was long and fruitful, but we will find solutions and we are able, unfortunately, to carry on without Russia.
Translated from French. The French original prevails.




