Home / Opinion / JOURNEY TO THE LAND OF Dostoevsky

JOURNEY TO THE LAND OF Dostoevsky

The journalist and film-maker Tahar Houchi shares his impressions of a trip to Russia, where he travelled to attend the Kazan International Muslim Film Festival, founded in 2005. In the background lies an unprecedented international geopolitical crisis, which does not prevent the “universally unifying” Slavic soul “from embracing all peoples in one and the same love”1.

Russia has officially been at war since its invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022. The international media’s view of this vast country is largely critical, pessimistic and alarming. They report above all on the pressure its economy is under, on the repression meted out to opponents of President Putin’s political choices and, consequently, on the gloom taking hold of Russian citizens. Very little information reaches us from the inside, and few people know how Russians are really experiencing this international geostrategic crisis in which their country finds itself at the very centre.

We travelled there to attend the 20th International Muslim Film Festival, held from 6 to 11 September in the city of Kazan, and can say that the international media’s view of Dostoevsky’s country is not entirely wrong, but also that the situation is not as dramatic as they would have us believe. The ordinary existence of Russians is much like that of their “enemies” in Western Europe; their daily life is even somewhat more relaxed, for Russians undeniably have a gift for making life strangely cheerful and carefree.

Monday 6 September, 6pm: our plane lands at Kazan International Airport, capital of Tatarstan. This republic of more than 8,500 lakes is one of the most important in the Russian Federation. Police checks are very strict, and the expressionless border officers give a rather cold welcome to any visitor who ventures into Putin’s country at this time of tension. We can already feel the effects of the war, even if they are less visible than in Moscow. Sofiane, an Algerian director who had come to present his film, told us that he had been left without an internet connection for several hours after his arrival. “The GPS signal is sometimes cut. This is done to throw any Ukrainian drones off course“, he was told.

Other signs of the crisis can be seen in the low numbers of foreign travellers, and in the duty-free area, reduced to a single shop with empty shelves. None of the Western European luxury goods Russians adore are left, nor any international brands. In this way, the war discreetly makes itself known to the foreign traveller.

A Christian, Muslim and modern city

The road into Kazan is clear and almost empty. The city centre is deserted, which is normal for a weekday, but visitors may wrongly take it as a sign of social malaise. Otherwise, everything seems to be working normally. Very quickly, one discovers the impact of the sanctions, which in reality hurt tourists more than citizens. The many guests of various nationalities who arrived in waves in Tatarstan to take part in the “Altyn minbar” festival, chaired by the Grand Mufti of Russia, learn to their disappointment that their many bank cards do not work. This forces them to make repeated trips to the banks to obtain roubles.

The next day, from the early hours, Bauman Street, the central, pedestrianised and emblematic thoroughfare of Kazan, gradually comes to life. It cuts across the city for about two kilometres, starting at the Kremlin and ending at Tukay Square. It is lined with benches, restaurants, bars and shops that vie with one another in originality, beauty and modernity. The Qolsharif Mosque, towering over the Kremlin, watches over it. The attention of tourists walking along it is quickly drawn to groups of girls, some cheerfully wearing skimpy outfits while others are proudly veiled, parading in procession along the busy street. One also notices the Christian places of worship, which add a touch of restraint to this street, whose brazen beauty, arrogance and prohibitive prices displayed in shop windows are an affront to Russian citizens on modest salaries.

Kazan thus openly displays its Islam, its Christianity and its modernity, without complexes or embarrassment. It is a mix that surprises tourists at first, but comes naturally to the people of Kazan. “It’s nothing unusual,” our guide, Elena, tells us. “Here we live and die together.”

Saving Russia through culture

Cultural life in the city is rich. Several events have been announced, including an upcoming meeting of the BRICS countries (from 22 to 24 October). The festival does not appear to be the most important of them, even though it is receiving all the attention. More than a hundred films from over 40 Muslim countries are on the programme. It is hard not to see in this event the skill with which the land of the great bear manages, promotes and capitalises on its relations with the countries of the Islamic world. Indeed, Arab countries rub shoulders with those of Central Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. The Senegalese director Moussa Touré is captivated by the richness of the festival. “This country inspires me greatly,” he told us. “In fact, I have already started writing a screenplay whose story will unfold between Senegal and Kazan.”

Attendance varies depending on the time of day. “The morning screenings are sparsely attended, because people are at work,” Svetlana, a festival volunteer, tells us. She adds: “In the evenings, on the other hand, especially on Fridays and Saturdays, we sometimes have to turn people away.” An event of this kind also serves to give citizens a sense that life is normal. They devour the city’s abundant cultural offering with relish. With art lending a hand, daily life carries on normally and peacefully throughout the week. Apart from the high cost of living, the shortage of Western European products and the impact of sanctions on the use of international bank cards, visitors tend to forget that the country is officially at war. In this way, politicians are putting into practice Dostoevsky’s idea that “Beauty will save the world.”

A hectic life

From Friday evening, the city comes alight. The streets fill with crowds of revellers converging on the main street. Street performers, buskers and musicians each take up their places in their own way to offer entertainment and joy to an audience both won over and eager for more. Restaurant terraces fill up, and hands shuttle happily back and forth between generous plates, glasses of alcohol and hungry mouths. Within a few hours, heated spirits give themselves over to a merging of joys, impromptu dancing and bursts of laughter that are drowned out in the hubbub of the neighbouring terraces. From the sky, it would look like a chaotic symphony.

In Moscow, the Moroccan directors Jaouad and Aziz, together with the Algerian director, report that life is even more intense. “The city never sleeps, there is an endless parade of luxury cars, groups of young people fly from one bar to the next like swarms of bees, and the music never stops in the many nightspots,” says Sofiane, not without astonishment. This hectic life presents itself as an antidote to war. Each in their own way embodies the idea of the author of Crime and Punishment: “To live, no matter how, but to live!“

At around 11pm, the night-time party venues begin to swallow up young people in waves. The interiors vary, but they all offer the same things: blazing dance floors on which people throw themselves into frenzied dancing, bars stocked with local alcoholic drinks, shows as burlesque and electric as they are erotic, and karaoke. Groups of young people sing at the tops of their voices and rub up against one another. All this is happening at a time when young Russians are fighting at the front. Nobody gives it a thought. And when you ask the question, the answers are as spontaneous as they are disconcerting. Dimitri, a young bar owner, told us something along these lines: “There are roughly 100 million of us Russians and we have a million professionals, well paid, who do their job well. We support them while we carry on living, sometimes drunk”. Elena, his employee, chimed in: “We are a great country and we are patriots ”. That view, however, is not shared by Murat, who spends his time window-shopping along the high street. All he dreams of is leaving the country. “Life is becoming impossible here, too hard and too expensive. Ordinary people like me are condemned to work for pitiful wages or to leave the country, when they are not called up to serve.” Hemmed in on all sides, some seek salvation in drunkenness and oblivion, others in a faint hope of reaching a sky they dream will be kinder, for “To live without hope is to cease to live”, as the author of Poor Folk wrote.

The older generation, who find these drink-fuelled, frenzied nights hard to bear, can be found during the day at the Marina. They come to enjoy the Olympian calm that reigns there and the sun’s last appearances before its winter exile, soon to be driven away by the bitter cold, which can reach minus 30 degrees.

The invisible yet deafening war

Daily life, then, shows no sign of the deafening war. The media, too, tend to mention it so discreetly that any reference to it takes people by surprise. The war is all but drowned out by the silence of the media and by a festive life washed down with beer and vodka. Yet some find it hard to ignore. One of them is Catarina, who works at Kazan’s central station. “It’s true that the media say little about the war, but its shrapnel spatters us every day,” she tells us. “Every now and then we see a young man with one leg, a bandaged head, a maimed hand, she laments. Out of discretion, we don’t ask anything, but we easily understand that these are war wounded.”

Indeed, the signs of war have to be searched for, just as Sherlock Homes searches for clues to a crime. Yet they are there. Even so, this does not stop Russians from living life to the full: working all week and partying to excess all weekend long. The war thus becomes commonplace, as the author of The Brothers Karamazov wrote: “A being who gets used to everything – that, I think, is the best definition of man.“

Anyone strolling through the city will easily notice the prominence of culture and history in the artworks scattered across it: statues, historic monuments and the minarets of handsome mosques in brilliant white, which vie with those of dull-coloured churches. Visitors will also notice the swarthy, even black, faces that stand out against those of the Russians. These faces belong to the contingents of African and North African students who, with access to Europe becoming ever harder, have made Russia a destination of choice. They see it as an El Dorado of learning that has dethroned Western Europe. They come to study computer science, biology, medicine, engineering… It is also a godsend for the country, allowing it to strengthen its ties with a world once beholden to the Old Continent.

Russia, an El Dorado for African and North African students

Such is the case of Amadou, a Malian master’s student in computer science, who has found happiness in the land of the Tatars. “Life here is cheap. This city offers me a lot of support with housing, access to knowledge and living costs “, he explains. Thiziri, an Algerian biology student, came to Kazan following her uncle. ” Besides the convenience of having somewhere to land, this country gives us the comfort of not being subjected to racism, as happens in France“, she says. ” There are lots of odd jobs that allow us to pay for our studies, she adds.”

Socially, Russians are kind, warm and friendly. It is easy to fit in. Liza, a Tunisian student, confirms how easy social integration is. ” I made a circle of friends easily and quickly. People here don’t put up barriers“, she says happily.

None of these students are prepared for life in a country whose language is utterly foreign to them, where winter is an ordeal because temperatures plunge so low, and whose way of life is diametrically opposed to their own. Yet none of this is an insurmountable obstacle. The language is soon learned and the winter quickly tamed. One thing remains that everyone complains about: the food. Here, as Liza tells us, the solution is easily found: “even if Russian food isn’t great, I regularly cook all my favourite dishes at home“, she says. Despite the difficulties, all the students speak of their delight at the tolerance and open-mindedness of the Republic of Tatarstan, which motivate and encourage them to press on.

While it is genuinely easy to obtain a degree, life after graduation remains a problem. At the end of their studies, foreign students face a dilemma: return home to a risky readjustment or stay and take on the cumbersome administrative machine that grinds people down mercilessly. Marriage is often the way out, as the route to legal status through an employment contract puts employers off – because of the taxes they must then pay. This dead end thus inevitably drives some into illegality and spells out a chronicle of a tragedy foretold.

A road to paradise that leads nowhere

Very early in the morning, we set off for the airport. The city’s thoroughfares are empty, and the roar of the engine reminds us of the whirring of helicopter rotors over the Russian-Ukrainian border. The city struggles to wake; war murmurs; the conscience of the Russians slumbers; the hope of foreign students glimmers. As these thoughts jostle in our minds, a few trees lining the road, spaced at equal distances from one another, file past our eyes through the window, like soldiers returning from a battlefield. The plane gathers speed and takes off, and the passengers hope not to cross paths with a Ukrainian drone. We land in Europe and notice that people here are no different from the Russians, save for the latter’s carefree attitude. Thus the citizens of the world, some amid deafening media clamour, others amid a clamorous silence, cede their power to politicians who run this world as they please. Meanwhile, everyone nurtures the hope of a better world. “To live without hope is to cease to live.”

  1. F. M. Dostoevsky, Pushkin Speech (1880). ↩︎

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.