Home / Conflicts / Israel, Iran and the shadow of a major conflict: between a real nuclear threat and a strategic obsession

Israel, Iran and the shadow of a major conflict: between a real nuclear threat and a strategic obsession

For more than two decades, the Islamic Republic of Iran has posed a major strategic threat to Israel, particularly because of its nuclear programme. Tehran, which long concealed the extent of its sensitive nuclear activities, now stands on the verge of the critical uranium enrichment threshold that would allow rapid weaponisation. This progress is fuelling deep concern in both Jerusalem and Washington, but it is above all Benjamin Netanyahu who, since his first terms in office, has made the “neutralisation of the Iranian threat” the core of his security doctrine.

A very real nuclear threat

Since the 2000s, Iran has developed a civilian nuclear capability officially intended for energy production. Yet successive revelations by the IAEA, leaks from Western and Israeli intelligence services and persistent ambiguities surrounding underground facilities such as Fordow and Natanz leave little doubt about Tehran’s intention eventually to acquire a nuclear weapons capability. The 2015 Vienna agreement (JCPOA), negotiated with the major powers, had put this process on hold. But the unilateral withdrawal of the United States in 2018 under Donald Trump revived Iran’s nuclear momentum. Today, according to several reports, Iran is believed to have enough enriched uranium to build one or two warheads within a few months, even though the step to an actual weapon remains hypothetical and politically risky for Tehran.

For Israel, a nuclear Iran constitutes an existential casus belli. Iran is one of the only countries to fundamentally contest the legitimacy of the Jewish state, while actively supporting hostile armed groups through its proxies (Hezbollah, Hamas, the Houthis). An Iranian bomb would therefore not merely serve as a deterrent; it could redefine the regional balance of power, erode Israel’s military superiority and open the door to proliferation in the Gulf (Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Turkey). It is against this backdrop that the Israeli government’s offensive doctrine, and more specifically Netanyahu’s obsession, must be understood.

Netanyahu’s strategic obsession and the risks of escalation

Benjamin Netanyahu, who has served several times as Prime Minister of Israel since the 1990s, built his international standing on one red line: preventing Iran from obtaining the bomb at all costs. Sabotage of facilities, targeted assassinations of Iranian nuclear scientists, massive diplomatic pressure on the United States: everything has been tried. Since 7 October and the war against Hamas — backed and armed by Iran — the risk of direct confrontation between Jerusalem and Tehran has never been higher.

Leaks suggest that the Israeli general staff regularly updates plans for strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, with or without a green light from Washington. Such action — even if pre-emptive and targeted — could set off a major regional conflagration, drawing in Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen and Iraqi Shia militias. The front could become global.

Trump, Netanyahu and the American factor

The stance of US President Donald Trump, who returned to power after the failure of Joe Biden’s second term, adds a further layer of unpredictability. Although Trump had previously backed Israel unreservedly, going so far as to recognise Jerusalem as its capital, his personal relationship with Netanyahu has deteriorated badly since the last Israeli elections and the latter’s public criticism of him in 2021. Trump has never got over what he sees as a form of political betrayal.

Today, while broadly in favour of a hard line against Iran, Trump may be less inclined to back Netanyahu in a unilateral military adventure. Pragmatic and focused on direct American interests, Trump could, in a U-turn typical of his style, rein in an uncoordinated Israeli strike, particularly if he considers it harmful to the US economy or likely to cause losses among troops in the region. Conversely, if Iran were to launch a pre-emptive or massive attack, Trump could respond with disproportionate force, risking dragging the United States into all-out conflict.

In this unstable configuration, the web of alliances is becoming blurred, and the personal factor between two populist leaders with outsized egos — Trump and Netanyahu — could paradoxically heighten the risk of things spiralling out of control, at a time when cool, calculated diplomacy is needed more than ever. The entire region remains at the mercy of their moods, caught between strategy, rivalry and revenge.

Sébastien Boussois, PhD in Political Science, researcher in geopolitics, scientific associate at CNAM Paris (Security and Defence Team) and Director of the IGE (Institut Géopolitique Européen)

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.