Home / International Geneva / Law of war: in Geneva, states put to the test of action

Law of war: in Geneva, states put to the test of action

More than 160 states have taken part in drawing up recommendations to better protect the victims of armed conflict. Meeting in Geneva on 3 and 4 November, governments and humanitarian actors are preparing a high-level conference in Jordan. The challenge: to carry diplomatic commitments through into military decisions.

Protecting a hospital, safeguarding a drinking water network, preventing the dehumanisation of the enemy: the rules of war are measured by concrete decisions. It is on this ground that the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) intends to bring states back, as civilians bear the consequences of more than 130 armed conflicts around the world.

The Global Dialogue on International Humanitarian Law, organised by Switzerland and the ICRC on 3 and 4 November in Geneva, brings together representatives of more than a hundred states. Opened by the Swiss State Secretary Alexandre Fasel and the President of the ICRC, Mirjana Spoljaric, the meeting is to examine the results of two years of consultations. It is paving the way for the “Humanity in War” conference, scheduled for 7 December in Amman under the auspices of King Abdullah II. eda.admin.ch

The initiative stems from a worrying observation: the protections provided by the law are being weakened, even in the way belligerents interpret their obligations. The ICRC condemns increasingly permissive readings of the rules, or even their outright disregard. Behind the legal controversies, it is the conditions for the survival of populations that are deteriorating.

A coalition that transcends the fault lines

Launched in September 2024 by Brazil, China, France, Jordan, Kazakhstan and South Africa, together with the ICRC, the initiative brings together countries with very different diplomatic outlooks. This diversity is one of its main strengths: it allows the defence of humanitarian law to be championed beyond a single geopolitical camp. International Committee of the Red Cross

The figures, however, cover distinct realities. More than 160 states took part in the consultations, while 127 have formally joined the initiative. Twenty-seven states led the thematic discussions. This mobilisation reflects a capacity for dialogue; it does not yet guarantee common application on the battlefield.

Seven areas were explored, ranging from the prevention of violations to naval warfare, by way of national humanitarian law committees, the links between IHL and peace, civilian infrastructure, hospitals and digital technologies. The common thread: giving authorities the means to build the protection of people into their day-to-day operations. International Committee of the Red Cross

Protecting the conditions for survival

The recommendations set out by the ICRC focus in particular on preserving essential services: healthcare, water, sanitation, electricity and communications. They envisage protected zones around vital infrastructure, better coordination between civilian and military actors, and safe sea lanes for supplies.

This approach takes account of a key reality of contemporary conflict: the damage inflicted on infrastructure can spread far beyond the site of an attack. The protection of civilians must therefore be built into the planning of operations, with attention paid to the services on which an entire population depends.

Another significant strand is countering rhetoric that portrays certain groups as less deserving of protection. The language used to describe the enemy, public conduct and the use of social media by authorities or armed forces thus become matters for prevention. Dehumanisation threatens the very principle of protection that applies to everyone.

Digital technologies also call for greater vigilance. The ICRC stresses the continuous verification and cross-checking of information on potential targets. The ever-faster flow of data makes this requirement especially crucial: having information quickly never removes the need to assess its reliability.

Amman: a test of political responsibility

These recommendations are non-binding. Their impact will depend on how they are reflected in states’ training, procedures and decisions. Their status does not, however, make optional the obligations under humanitarian law to which they seek to give more effective application.

In Amman, a political declaration is due to be issued at the close of the leaders’ conference. International Committee of the Red Cross The challenge will be to give it practical follow-through: clearly assigned responsibilities, resources and monitoring of commitments.

Geneva offers a space in which to build this common ground despite the antagonisms. Its success, however, will be measured far from the conference rooms: by the ability to care for the wounded, to preserve essential services and to protect those who are not taking part in the fighting. It is at that level that the commitments made by states will take on their meaning.

Translated from French. The French original prevails.

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

La Tribune des Nations

La Tribune des Nations dans votre boîte mail

Les dernières analyses de nos universitaires et journalistes sur la Genève internationale, la diplomatie et les conflits.

Gratuit. Désabonnement en un clic. Voir notre politique de confidentialité.